Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Crazy Monkey Defense Opinions

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    Originally posted by Mackan View Post
    And what is his lineage in BJJ, since he does "Monkey Jits" aswell?
    http://www.crazymonkeydefense.com/monkey-jits/

    About Rodney King

    When Rodney first brought Brazilian Jiu Jitsu to South Africa in 1998, there were only 2 people in the whole country offering Brazilian Jiu Jitsu training. In 1998 after receiving his Blue Belt from Rigan Machado, he traveled to Brazil to continue his training.

    In the subsequent years Rodney has coached Brazilian Jiu Jitsu around the world, offering his unique approach, that focuses on play, challenge and performance — while avoiding hyper-competitiveness, and the ‘Meathead’ mentally so prevalent today in many Brazilian Jiu Jitsu schools.

    As a 3rd degree Black Belt, under his teacher and Brazilian Jiu Jitsu legend, Rigan Machado, Rodney honors Rigan’s philosophy of the ‘Uncomplicated Game’, coaching his clients in what REALLY works, while having fun doing it!
    http://www.monkeyjits.com/

    looks like you have to be a member to see all the good stuff
    but any sort of online BJJ school with online grading typically isn't going to wow anyone here.

    Comment


      #17
      Originally posted by goodlun View Post
      looks like you have to be a member to see all the good stuff
      but any sort of online BJJ school with online grading typically isn't going to wow anyone here.
      Yeah...

      I listen to the videos and it seems that what he is selling is very "non-sport", "ranks apply in our organisation" and such. Not that necessarily means that it sucks, only... Terms and conditions.

      Cool. Thx.

      Comment


        #18
        I really don't want to get into a flame war here. And I'm defenately not going to go down the 'sport vs. street' route either. But...

        Originally posted by goodlun View Post


        Comparing CMD certification style to that of BJJ doesn't mesh up well.
        BJJ has always had one big quality control element. Its sport aspects. The fact it was used in MMA and Grappling. The competing kept BJJ Honest. You also could tell if what you where learning worked by pressure testing it.
        I agree with this about BJJ for the most part. But honest towards what end? At the same time there are some in the BJJ community (like some of the Gracie's) who have argued that overly competitive environments have made BJJ less effective for the street. Ii know, I know, the 'deadly street'. But for some this is important. Without a doubt, the competition leads to innovation, really amazing displays, creativity. I want to be clear I am NOT down on competition. But for me, competition isn't really the matrix through which I judge an art, other than if is good in competition. MMA is awesome, and is generally a lot more street effective than RBSD or something though.

        But competition and pressure testing are two different things.


        CMD being taught in schools without this pressure testing is the issue. Sidekicks is a perfect example. This isn't a school that is using CMD in an alive manner. They are not using it for boxing or MT.
        How do you know? How do you define pressure testing? As all out, balls to the wall sparing? Pressure testing should be progressive. More to the point, while it might not be hardcore enough for you, not everyone wants to spar. We can argue if this is a good or bad thing, but it is a fact. Most MMA gyms, muay thai, or boxing gyms, I have been in did NOT teach sparring to everyone. You needed to do either personal training, or small group classes to spar, and then you got to jump in with the regular sparing group. This is how it works for CM too. If people want to spar, that is an option. But not everyone wants or can do that. I think you need to get out more if you don't realize that this is COMMON in more striking arts, not an exception. I haven't been to Swift Kick, I'm not 100% sure how they work. I would imagine that pressure testing is done everyday, but fully resistive sparing is probably for those few that chose this option. This is no different than EVERY MMA GYM I have ever been in or heard of. There are multiple streams. But to restate, many in CM do spar, regularly.


        Its a line on their resume to make their school look a bit less like shit.
        This is totally an unsubstantiated opinion. How do you know that it isn't the reverse, where CM is the love, and the other is for money (not saying it is, but it just as substantiated as the above).


        It chips away greatly at CMD quality control. When you have instructors who have not themselves pressure tested it and don't continue to do so.
        Not sure what you mean by pressure test, you seem to be equating it to what, competition? First off, there are many good coaches out there in a variety of sports that never competed but are good, sometimes great coaches. Secondly, how do you know how much he pressure tests what he does? Where are you getting your information from? Would really like to know? How long did you train there?


        Even worse you have instructors that don't have a vehicle in which to employ it with.
        you can think of CMD as a turbo charger doesn't do you damn bit of good if you don't have an engine setup right to put it on.
        This statement, along with the part where you mention if its not 'trained with boxing or muay thai', tells me you know absolutly nothing about what you are talking about. Lik zero. Like you should shut up because you are totally uninforment about what you are saying. You seem to think that CMD is a hand position/stance/blocking technique. It is an entire striking system, that incoporates boxing and muay thai into it. I'll say it again, CMD is not a hand position. You don't just take the hand position and start doing TKD or something. Is that what you think is happening? You are essentially using boxing hands, with a modified stance, higher guard, as well as low line MT kicks, clinch work that also has some wrestling influence, with various elbows, knees etc. That is CMD. You would know this if your only point of reference wasn't a youtube clip or some 15 year old forum chatter.

        If you are at a place that actively competes and have incorporated CMD into the syllabus and are winning competitions great.
        Are you saying that the only way to judge the worth of a martial art is how it does in competion. First, this is only a fair judge of CMD if it is being marketed as the 'ultimate' stand up for MMA, or as some B.S. way to stop MMA fighters without all the hard work (like a lot of RBSD for example). It is not.

        Secondly, some of the principles of the CMD HAVE absolutely been incorporated in the games of mixed martial artists...including anyone who trains standup at SBG (who were cut off from the material about a decade ago). The guard itself has been used by many high level MMA fighters. Rodney has also trained at least one major fighter in S. Africa.

        CMD being taught at a school doesn't mean shit if that school isn't competing with it.
        Pressure testing is not the same as competing. I have been to many good schools, like a student Paul Vunak (PFS school) for example, where I don't think anyone 'competed'. They pressure tested though. And most of them spared. And they would likely tear your face off. In other words, competing in fights is not always equivilent to how well something works. I do personally think that to take any striking or grappling art to its highest level in terms of efficacy, there should be sparring at some point, and it should be regular. But just like in the MT gyms I've been in, there are many who just don't want to go down that road. Let me also repeat, that MMA fighters have been trained using CMD...it is not just some made up system that hasn't been tested. It is also not just a system that only highly compitive people can train it (like every other striking art).



        WOW what a bunch of bullshit. Lets use your BJJ analogy.
        This happens one of 2 ways typically.
        They bring in an actual vetted BJJ Instructor into their school. This is good. Students learn from someone that knows what the fuck they are doing.
        or
        The guy try's and teach BJJ himself after going to a few seminars. This is bad.
        Hate to break it to you kid (because I'm assuming you're fairly young, or at least weren't really involved in BJJ in the late 1990's early 2000's) but at least around here, it is really the second that applies. I can think of 4 of the top BJJ instructor's in this city who learned exactly according to #2. And they are awesome. They went to seminars, did private training, and had someone down for seminars a few times a year. They didn't bring anyone down to teach full time at the studo (I only know one place that did this). MMA wasn't as blown up as now, and it just wasn't financially feasable to do pay someone to relocate. So it isn't bullshit. It's a reality. Now things are different for BJJ because it blew up. And that's good. But it absolutely was not the norm. As a matter of fact. I can think of one gym that actually started as some guys watching tapes together and training, letting people pay a mat fee to join in. Then they became affliated, and started the process I've said above.


        They don't have the underlying base to really teach an alive method like CMD.
        I know for a fact that owner of Swift Kick spars and pressure tests. CMD is the underlying base to pressure test itself. Just like how you don't need to train Muay Thai to pressure test boxing.



        No one here said shit about sports psychology. Not a single person. No one bad talked it. So what the fuck are you smoking?
        was just clarifying for Fuzzy, who mentioned that there is a "disturbing trend in Mr. King's channel" regarding life coaching. I'm just trying to say, I don't really see anything spiritual, certainly not even close to on the level of what you might here, for example at your local yoga studio. It is really just a particular take on the psychology of combat. The dude is writing his PH.d in it.

        Mackan

        He is a black belt under Rigan Machado.

        And no, there is NO ONLINE ranking for BJJ through King. You don't submit a video and say, get a blue belt.

        Comment


          #19
          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          I really don't want to get into a flame war here. And I'm defenately not going to go down the 'sport vs. street' route either. But...
          Just a friendly discussion nothing more.



          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          But honest towards what end?
          Well at the very least that it works in competition. This is a great deal more than a lot of arts can claim.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          At the same time there are some in the BJJ community (like some of the Gracie's) who have argued that overly competitive environments have made BJJ less effective for the street.
          and they are full of shit.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          But competition and pressure testing are two different things.
          Competition is the only real pressure testing most arts will ever see. Lets face it modern day life is fairly civilized. Its rather easy for people to go through their entire lives now without ever having to get physical with someone.
          Competition at the very least pressure test the art against what ever rule set they are using. This is miles better than theorizing. As you already stated your probably better off in MMA to learn self defense than most RBSD.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          How do you define pressure testing?
          It pretty much says all on the tin. Testing your art under pressure. Real pressure where you have to deal with adrenalin dumps and nerves. Where their is something to be gained or lost even if its just a match.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          not everyone wants to spar.
          I don't give a fuck what everyone wants to do or not do.
          You can't seriously make an argument that a style can be pressure tested without full contact sparing and competing can you?


          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          Most MMA gyms, muay thai, or boxing gyms, I have been in did NOT teach sparring to everyone.
          Now I know your full of shit. With this that friendly thing just went out the window.
          You are a fucking liar you have never stepped foot into a MMA, MT, Boxing, or BJJ gym in your life. Your comments about sparing and pressure testing prove that you know fuck all about aliveness. Given that you don't understand the basics your far from capable of judging CMD or any martial art.


          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          This is how it works for CM too. If people want to spar, that is an option. But not everyone wants or can do that.
          Proof that CMs quality control is now gone.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          I haven't been to Swift Kick, I'm not 100% sure how they work. I would imagine that pressure testing is done everyday, but fully resistive sparing is probably for those few that chose this option.
          Explain to me how one pressure test an art without Fully restive sparring? No really go on explain that to me. Swift Kicks is a fucking joke and apparently now Crazy Monkey has become one as well.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          This is no different than EVERY MMA GYM I have ever been in or heard of. There are multiple streams. But to restate, many in CM do spar, regularly.
          LMAO you are so full of shit its not even funny.


          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          This is totally an unsubstantiated opinion. How do you know that it isn't the reverse, where CM is the love, and the other is for money (not saying it is, but it just as substantiated as the above).
          Are you really this dumb?

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          Are you saying that the only way to judge the worth of a martial art is how it does in competion.
          Not exactly, I love the Dog Brothers and they don't have formal competition but if you ever watch a gathering of the pack you will see that they meet the definition of pressure testing. However they are really kind of the exemption to the rule. Yes, yes you need a high stress free form competition to pressure test.


          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          Secondly, some of the principles of the CMD HAVE absolutely been incorporated in the games of mixed martial artists...including anyone who trains standup at SBG (who were cut off from the material about a decade ago). The guard itself has been used by many high level MMA fighters. Rodney has also trained at least one major fighter in S. Africa.
          I actually don't doubt that Crazy monkey has some good things in it. The concern I raised was the quality control, which was doubled down on when I saw the fact that they let the ass hats at swift kicks teach it.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          Hate to break it to you kid (because I'm assuming you're fairly young
          I am 34
          I have been grappling off and on for a very long time. Since I was a kid this includes BJJ at Fabio Santos and Judo at Judo America.

          I live in San Diego area. If you want you can go and see the list of ADCC winners 4 or 5 of them live in my city.

          Show me a champion that has learned via correspondence courses.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          I know for a fact that owner of Swift Kick spars and pressure tests. CMD is the underlying base to pressure test itself. Just like how you don't need to train Muay Thai to pressure test boxing.
          You don't know shit about Swift Kick or its owner. If you did you wouldn't be asking such stupid fucking questions.

          Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
          Mackan

          He is a black belt under Rigan Machado.

          And no, there is NO ONLINE ranking for BJJ through King. You don't submit a video and say, get a blue belt.
          How well is King's blue belts doing in competition?

          Comment


            #20
            Just a friendly discussion nothing more.
            Great. A friendly, knowledgeable conversation would be great.

            Now I know your full of shit. With this that friendly thing just went out the window.
            That's a shame. I'm going to keep this friendly though, because I don't really let things people say on the internet fire me up.

            Well at the very least that it works in competition. This is a great deal more than a lot of arts can claim.
            In terms of BJJ, I 100% agree with you. It's a great and beautiful art. And I have nothing but respect for high level competitors, and I have no doubt that many (most) of them would do just fine on the street.

            and they are full of shit.
            That's your opinion. I tend to respect the family that created and us the beautiful art of BJJ. And no offense intended, I tend to take their opinion a little more seriously than you. I'm crazy like that. I also agree with them, that people can be great at jiujitsu without having to compete a ton AND that people can be great by competing a ton. There is room for both.

            Why? Because both pressure test through rolling. Because pressure testing is not equivalent to competition. Competition is a form of pressure testing. And if that's where someone wants his or her game to go, that's awesome. But it's not for everyone. And it doesn't have to be.

            Which leads me to this stuff:

            Competition is the only real pressure testing most arts will ever see.
            It strikes me that we might have different ideas of what competition implies. For me it means engaging in a competitive match, usually as part of some kind of event. I don't, for example, equate rolling with competition. And I don't like rolling with those who do.

            So are you saying that rolling is not pressure testing. Because according to your statement, "competition is the only REAL pressure testing [...]". So therefore, I take it you don't see rolling as pressure testing. I have to say, I am in complete disagreement and have never, ever, heard this said before (that rolling is not pressure testing).

            Competition at the very least pressure test the art against what ever rule set they are using. This is miles better than theorizing.
            Yeah, pressure testing is necessary. As I say, I don't think competition is the only form of pressure testing. It can be a good one though.

            And I don't think that anyone who practices CMD is 'theorizing'. Everyone pressure tests along a spectrum. Just like how a lot of BJJ guys pressure test only to a certain point. For example, through rolling. Some go beyond this, and do competition. Some go beyond this and do MMA or vale tudo. But this last group is more rare. You seem to have set the bench mark at 'competition'. But what kind? Is just grappling really enough of a pressure test for you? Have you done MMA, that is participated in a NHB style event? If not, by your own standards, have you pressure tested your art? If not, why?

            I ask, because you seem to be making the claim that a martial artist to be decent needs to pressure test (which I agree with), but that the only "real" pressure testing, is competition. So, in questioning the basis of your claim, I have to ask if you have met its fundamental assumptions. In other words, if you are going to come down on a particular practitioner for not being good enough for not competing in MMA, as well as suggesting that everyone who doesn't practice in this way can't
            I.
            seriously make an argument that a style can be pressure tested without full contact sparing and competing can you?
            Then I want to know what your benchmark for pressure testing is, especially when you are calling mine into question. For example, it seems based on what you say here:

            am 34
            I have been grappling off and on for a very long time. Since I was a kid this includes BJJ at Fabio Santos and Judo at Judo America.
            have never actually participated in an MMA event. Have you ever actually practiced your art against someone actively trying to punch you in the face etc? If not, then by your own standards, have you pressure tested it?

            You have pressure tested it, like you say, in regards to the context of grappling. And that is, like you also say, a lot better than those who don't pressure test at all. But let's be honest here, you're not an MMA fighter. You don't, from what I can see, even do any striking. In other words, you have set your personal bench mark for pressure testing at a particular point along a spectrum. You have without a doubt pressure tested, but not to the end of that spectrum (which btw would not be MMA, but in a truly anything goes environment, and that would be nuts).

            Do you see where I'm going with this?

            Now, let's move on for a moment, because I would like to deal with this, because I think it says a lot about what you generally brought to this conversation, and the level you have taken (down) to.

            Now I know your full of shit. With this that friendly thing just went out the window.
            You are a fucking liar you have never stepped foot into a MMA, MT, Boxing, or BJJ gym in your life. Your comments about sparing and pressure testing prove that you know fuck all about aliveness. Given that you don't understand the basics your far from capable of judging CMD or any martial art.
            This is great classic example of fallacious ad hominem, and really, unfortunately, discredits much of what you have said.

            How could you possibly know that "I have never stepped foot into an MMA, MT, BOxing or BJJ gym in [my] life?". This is a totally unsubstantiated claim you are making, something which you can not possibly know, and which is completely lacking in evidence. Which is pretty much par for the course for your level of rhetoric and your general apparent ignorance on this topic. I think this stands in direct contradiction to the values that this site was founded upon.

            Yet, despite not being possibly able to know this, you then precede to use it as a (false) proof, that I don't know anything, and therefore my claims are invalid. Nice shortcut to thinking there. May I suggest a high school level class in critical thinking or perhaps logical argumentation?

            In fact, because you don't know whether or not I have been in an MMA gym (for the record I have, so there), the rest of your statement is void. Easy enough.

            But what I'd also like to point out is how much of pretty much all your posts on this thread are based on a lack of either experiential or any other actual knowledge in what you are talking about. I tried to make you understand this in my last post, where I noted how you seem to think that CMD is a position or some kind of plug in for boxing or MT (when you said you needed to train it with boxing and Muay Thai for example). This is a statement that fundamentally betrays a total lack of understanding as to CMD is (a 'stand alone' stand up system, with roots in boxing and Muay Thai, and with in many ways very similar training protocols).

            But let's move on again.

            I said
            This is no different than EVERY MMA GYM I have ever been in or heard of. There are multiple streams. But to restate, many in CM do spar, regularly.
            To which you responded:

            LMAO you are so full of shit its not even funny.
            Another proof of your mastery of logic, rhetoric, and ability to engage in anything approximating adult conversation. Sad that you say

            I am 34
            Because I honestly thought I was speaking to a teenager. My bad.

            But let me speak to your 'point'.
            No. I am not full of shit. 'LMAO'. How's that? That's about all I really need to counter that level of argument.

            But, let me do more, and assume you genuinely want to know about this.

            I haven't ever been in an MMA gym where everyone had to spar standup. Everyone who wants to rank in BJJ absolutely needs to spar. The only time I have seen this 'rule' lifted is for people with serious handicaps, who do their best, and are given, say, a blue belt for their efforts. This has happened in one of the best MMA gyms I have ever been in. There, the instructor's know how to meet people where they are. This is also the ideal CM strives for. It might not be your thing. It seems you really enjoy competition. It seems you equate rolling with competition (?). It seems you think, for example, jiujitsu is primarily above competition. I genuinely feel bad that you have learned so little from that art.

            Let me be clear about this for a moment. Sparring is an option for everyone who practices Crazy Monkey. It's there. It works in that environment. For example, Rodney King has trained a number of MMA fighters, like Costa Ioannou, who is, I think, still undefeated in the EFC (high level S. African MMA comp).

            Let me give an example of what I mean by different streams. The three places I have trained Muay Thai (and no, I don't consider myself as anything an expert in it), there were a serious of different classes. You can a beginners class (the biggest), which consisted mostly of pad/bag work, conditioning, and footwork. You then had a 'level 2' class. That was much the same, but ramped up, and involved working the clinch. In level 3 (which was always by invitation only) you could start sparing. Some people weren't invited. Some people chose not to do it. Some people tried it and went back to the other classes. Or did isolation sparring, but not knockdown. I can't fault them. They had lives, families, jobs, and they couldn't show up banged up all the time.

            So when you say:
            your comments about sparing and pressure testing prove that you know fuck all about aliveness.
            I have to shoot that back at you. Aliveness without a doubt includes sparring as yet another way of controlled combative interaction. But let's not forget what the concept was really meant to be about. It was not meant to be equated to fully balls-to-the-walls knockdown sparring. It was meant to counter the TMA practice of one step prearranged drills and movement patterns. Training alive includes things like non-prearranged drills, variable resistance, pad work, bag work, isolation sparring etc. Everyone is Crazy Monkey does these, just like anyone who takes a Muay Thai or boxing class does. But, just like in any gym I have been to (and apparently your experience is different here), not everyone ramps it all the way up to sparring.

            Explain to me how one pressure test an art without Fully restive sparring? No really go on explain that to me.
            Are we talking about pressure testing or fully pressure testing. How, for example, do BJJer's pressure test BJJ without engaging in vale tudo matches every practice? Does that seem silly? Well so does that question. Of course BJJ practitioners pressure test what they are doing on a regular basis, but in a controlled way. They have removed some of the variables. Let me be clear here, because I can already feel the steam coming out of your ears. I'm not trying to equate CM with BJJ over much. It is non-attribute based like BJJ, but there really is no equivilent in striking arts to the relative safety of rolling. In other words, like I said before, BJJ (and all grappling arts) art great in that you can train them fully resistive, for long periods of time, and still go to work the next day (or even right after). Striking arts are generally not like this.

            Where I think CM is different that others, is that the nature of the stance and the defense allows one to train with high levels of resistance while remaining relatively safe in terms of head shots. So it allows people who might not otherwise get into standup for fear of having their face punched it, to learn a functional system.

            How far they take that functionality is up to them. Just like in Muay Thai, or boxing, or Kyokushin etc. it is a choice to start to spar knockdown. I don't think this is news. You're not going to get kicked out of your gym/dojo whatever for not sparring. However, in Crazy Monkey there is, as I understand, a seperate ranking system for those who chose to spar (the glove system). This honors those who go this route. There is also a ranking system (if you could call it that) that honors those who continue to train in the art, practice in a functional and alive way that stops (by their choice) just short of full on sparring. Let me clear, this doesn't mean it is non-contact, or not alive. Just that, some people certain to occupy a particular place on the aliveness spectrum.

            Swift Kicks is a fucking joke and apparently now Crazy Monkey has become one as well.
            As far as I know, the CM program there is based on aliveness, the teacher spars regularly etc. He also has students into TMA. Two seperate things. I haven't been there, but this is what I have heard and I personally trust the source. Let me restate that from what I also understand, the video that was posted doesn't even really demonstrate what they do in their TMA stuff. It was a choreographed routine created by a 20 year kid done at charity event to raise money for a charity. How do I know this? I did what the kind of research this site was founded on (and that it's best investigations have done): I asked. Oh, and I understand they raised $7500 for charity at this thing. I know, what an asshole, right?

            It seems to me that you have taken that clip totally out of context and spun a whole narrative about it, as though it was ever meant to show the CMD practiced there. It was not. Shame on you for misrepresenting it as such without due diligence. Very similar to way you attempted just now to slander me, by calling me a liar.

            I don't post here very often these days, but I do read it often. I used to really respect the way this site was run. It was full of intelligent people trying to fight b.s. in martial arts. How are people like yourself getting away with your schtick here?

            The concern I raised was the quality control, which was doubled down on when I saw the fact that they let the ass hats at swift kicks teach it.
            I don't know what your infatuation is with Swift Kicks. You seem to have some strange vendetta against them. They have a family based program. They also teach CMD. Big deal. Over here, one of the top MMA gyms around, run by former UFC competitor, also teaches a popular 'modern' karate program, that includes this contemporary weapons demo stuff where you make up a routine. It's not a big deal to me. I can personally take the slight cognitive dissonance of two different and separate things happening at once. Maybe one day you will get there too.

            Show me a champion that has learned via correspondence courses.
            I don't think I could. I never suggested I could. The trainer's program isn't a correspondence course. I believe I have said this myself. You get material. You are not called a trainer. You work the material for at least year. You go to seminars, you have people down for seminars, if you live close to a trainer or above you go and visit all you can. You bust you're ass and then MAYBE in a year you are trainer. Then you do that same thing for FIVE YEARS (minimum) before you are actually a coach. You don't just tape yourself throwing air punches and then they send you a trainer certificate.

            How well is King's blue belts doing in competition?
            I don't know. I'm not an official representative, like I said at the outset. Do some research.

            Comment


              #21
              Strange double post thing
              Last edited by Tacitus; 5/08/2014 11:09pm, . Reason: Double post

              Comment


                #22
                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                That's your opinion. I tend to respect the family that created and us the beautiful art of BJJ. And no offense intended, I tend to take their opinion a little more seriously than you.



                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                Why? Because both pressure test through rolling.
                Rolling/sparring is not equal to pressure testing.
                Rolling is learning. Its not testing. Its about finding out the timing and what MAY work for you in a stressful situation. Rolling doesn't include the cocktail of chemicals that go through your brain when you get into a truly stressful situation. It doesn't start the fight or flight response. It doesn't test you under pressure. It is typically done with the same set of people day in and day out.
                Think of all the people you have encountered that are great in the comfort of their own gym rolling and sparring with their training partners that fail miserably and choke when they go and compete. It happens with any sort of competition. People who are great at home but when the pressure is on they freeze up. So no practicing is not pressure testing.

                Rolling is not pressure testing.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                Yeah, pressure testing is necessary. As I say, I don't think competition is the only form of pressure testing. It can be a good one though.
                I will admit that competition isn't the ONLY way. However what needs to be included in pressure testing is pressure. The ability to fail at it. One can't fail at sparring( or at least not in this sense). So sure you might be able to claim a belt test is a form of pressure testing and maybe a few other things but these are all minor things and in the grand scheme of things. Beyond the personal level. To have any sort of integrity at the Art level that art needs to include competing. At the very minim inter school competition and preferably inter discipline ones.


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                Everyone pressure tests along a spectrum.
                This is certainly true. I am fine with looking at it in that way. However for it to even fall onto the spectrum their has to be a competitive component.
                For example the Dog brothers




                do not host formal competions their are no declared winners or losers but they are doing something a bit more than "sparing" they are fighting to prove something to themselves. Where as sparing is about learning.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                if you are going to come down on a particular practitioner for not being good enough for not competing in MMA, as well as suggesting that everyone who doesn't practice in this way can't
                Really comes down to their claims. If I go to a BJJ gym and they claim to be a great BJJ gym I only care about their BJJ record. If I go to a MMA gym I care about their MMA record. If I go to a boxing gym I care guess what about their boxing record.
                If the BJJ gym claims it can get me ready for a MMA match then I expect that school to have pressure tested said claims in an MMA environment.
                I will take nearly any Martial sport to be sufficient for Self Defense as long as the school that is teaching it can at the very least perform well in their given sport.
                he leap from sport to self defense is actually very small.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                have never actually participated in an MMA event. Have you ever actually practiced your art against someone actively trying to punch you in the face etc? If not, then by your own standards, have you pressure tested it?
                Here is the thing, I make no claims to be an MMA fighter. I Don't claim that I can win a MMA fight. I know the limitations of what I train. I know to what level I have actually pressure tested it. I know how well I deal with the chemical cocktail that explodes in ones brain when they compete. I know how much I suck. I am not concerned with self defense. Its not one of the reasons I train.
                Also I have done striking. Shit mall Karate and some Boxing.


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                (for the record I have, so there),
                Bullshit


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                You can a beginners class (the biggest), which consisted mostly of pad/bag work, conditioning, and footwork. You then had a 'level 2' class. That was much the same, but ramped up, and involved working the clinch.
                Lets get to the meat of this right now. At those 2 levels would you say that they had been "pressure tested" would you say that they are ready for a fight?
                I am going to assume no. What they are doing is working themselves up to being able to spar. I am not saying a day on newbie should start of sparring. However the act of sparring is integral part of the art of MT. You can't progress in MT without sparring.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                In level 3 (which was always by invitation only) you could start sparing. Some people weren't invited. Some people chose not to do it. Some people tried it and went back to the other classes. Or did isolation sparring, but not knockdown. I can't fault them. They had lives, families, jobs, and they couldn't show up banged up all the time.
                If your just kicking pads your not learning MT.


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                I have to shoot that back at you. Aliveness without a doubt includes sparring as yet another way of controlled combative interaction. But let's not forget what the concept was really meant to be about. It was not meant to be equated to fully balls-to-the-walls knockdown sparring.
                Never claimed it was.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                But, just like in any gym I have been to (and apparently your experience is different here), not everyone ramps it all the way up to sparring.
                Its pretty damn hard to develop a sense of timing and distance without actually sparring meaning that your really lacking the aliveness department without it.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                Are we talking about pressure testing or fully pressure testing. How, for example, do BJJer's pressure test BJJ without engaging in vale tudo matches every practice?
                You seem really confused about the difference between practicing and testing.
                Practicing is about learning. Testing is about proving.
                If you want to prove your shit works in a vale tudo setting you must pressure test it in that setting.
                You don't however have to do a vale tudo match everyday to practice it.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                Let me clear, this doesn't mean it is non-contact, or not alive. Just that, some people certain to occupy a particular place on the aliveness spectrum.
                Your going to have to be clearer how you can have contact with aliveness without sparing.


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                It seems to me that you have taken that clip totally out of context and spun a whole narrative about it, as though it was ever meant to show the CMD practiced there
                . It was not. Shame on you for misrepresenting it as such without due diligence. Very similar to way you attempted just now to slander me, by calling me a liar.
                Hey liar, I did no such thing. I did not claim the video was CMD.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                I don't post here very often these days, but I do read it often. I used to really respect the way this site was run. It was full of intelligent people trying to fight b.s. in martial arts. How are people like yourself getting away with your schtick here?
                I stay out of the serious areas of the website. Maybe you didn't read where this was posted.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                I don't know what your infatuation is with Swift Kicks.
                Infatuation? Not at all, I am familiar with them and how shitty they are so when they popped up on the CMD search I pointed it out as a POSSIBLE quality control issue with CMD.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                You seem to have some strange vendetta against them.
                Not really I have made comments about them in this thread and maybe one other thread that was about them. Hardly call that a vendetta. They are a shitty school. They came up in this thread because they teach CMD. Its pretty much as simple as that.

                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                They have a family based program.
                So do a lot of gyms I respect. You seem to be missing the point. Swift Kicks sucks, not because they have a family program but because they are a major McDojo that teaches crappy martial arts.


                Originally posted by Tacitus View Post
                I don't think I could. I never suggested I could. The trainer's program isn't a correspondence course.
                Sure the hell sounds like one to me by both your description and theirs

                Comment


                  #23
                  *Grab popcorn* hmmm....fight!

                  Comment


                    #24
                    In all fairness I am being a bit too hard on Swift Kick. As Strip Mall McDojos go you could certainly do a hell of a lot worse. For their prices in San Diego area you certainly can do a hell of a lot better I and I do mean a HELL of a lot better. However that being said they are being unfairly shitted upon by me in order to irk other people and that is not fair to them.

                    Comment


                      #25
                      Originally posted by goodlun View Post
                      In all fairness I am being a bit too hard on Swift Kick. As Strip Mall McDojos go you could certainly do a hell of a lot worse. For their prices in San Diego area you certainly can do a hell of a lot better I and I do mean a HELL of a lot better. However that being said they are being unfairly shitted upon by me in order to irk other people and that is not fair to them.
                      No! Go back to being an ass to Tacticus, I still have popcorn left in the bowl!

                      Comment


                        #26
                        Milk, you'll have to put the popcorn away.

                        I just noticed that the posts by Nathan Wagar and Sam Kressin were inserted into this thread. Which is odd, because they definitely were not there before. Yet its says they were posted in December. I have the screen shots to prove they weren't there (I tend to screen shot all the posts I make these days, never know when they will be deleted/edited by mods). It's good that someone at bullshido, a site that bills itself as no b.s. and exposing the truth, decided to not censor these posts and actually put them up there. Even if, for some strange reason, it took six months.

                        Anyway, Nathan and Sam have way more experience than I do, and I would really suggest that, for anyone reading this thread, go read over what they say. Keep in mind they are a much better source on CMD than me. If someone is really interested in 'opinions' (plural, not just one anonymous forum member with absolutely zero personal experience) on Crazy Monkey Defense, they should consider the posts by those two. I think an intelligent reader can make up their own mind.

                        As to the rest of this 'debate', regarding pressure testing etc., I bow out. Believe it or not, I'm meeting up with some folks tomorrow to spar. I assume goodlum will be here though, saying something about this very comment instead.
                        As I say, I don't think it's hard to see who in this thread has enough actual first (or even second!) hand information to make an informed opinion on Crazy Monkey Defense.
                        Last edited by Tacitus; 5/10/2014 2:54am, .

                        Comment


                          #27
                          But...it's buttered popcorn...have you no heart?

                          Comment


                            #28
                            So...

                            Has anyone here ever rolled with a MonkeyJits practitioner?

                            Being blind, I can't really judge any footage of it. I kinda like the whole "anyone can participate" angle, also because I'm blind. However, am I the only one who sort of red flags the "we don't train to compete" and "our belts are for within our own organisation" and such?

                            Comment


                              #29
                              Originally posted by Mackan View Post
                              So...

                              Has anyone here ever rolled with a MonkeyJits practitioner?

                              Being blind, I can't really judge any footage of it. I kinda like the whole "anyone can participate" angle, also because I'm blind. However, am I the only one who sort of red flags the "we don't train to compete" and "our belts are for within our own organisation" and such?
                              How do you type and read if you're blind?

                              Comment


                                #30
                                Originally posted by Milk_ View Post
                                How do you type and read if you're blind?
                                I have a screen reader, called JAWS, and a "braille display" (I don't know if they are called that in english, but... A device that shows text in braille.)

                                Comment

                                Collapse

                                Edit this module to specify a template to display.

                                Working...
                                X