I think the thread title would be more accurate if the quotation marks were around the words 'wrestling match' instead of 'Throws'.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
12-Year-Old 'Throws' Wrestling Match So Boy With Cerebral Palsy Can Win
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by erezb View PostI think it was a weird and unnecessary show. If the disabled kid is able minded i can't see how this gives him any real satisfaction other than being the center of attention.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Tom .C View PostI think when the "Make A Wish" foundation needs somebody to kick dying little kids in the face, you'll be the goto guy.
Seriously though - I'm all for being nice to the chirruns. I just don't think this is nice. I think it's disrespectful to everyone involved to put them into this fucked up spectacle.
Comment
-
Originally posted by itwasntme View PostYou don't have the testicular fortitude.
To Tom and Azatdawn, you realize you are arguing two different points?
Comment
-
Interesting responses to this thread. I myself, cannot imagine, were I in the position of having a child of similar abilities, NOT allowing my kid to do this, if it's something he wanted to try. You all telling me if you had a kid with those abilities asking to try, and telling you he wants to try wrestling, and you'd look him in the eyes and say "sorry, you can't do that, you're not able to do that." Do you punish your able bodied children if they don't win the little league game too? At the age of 12 some schools don't even let sports teams win or lose (which is admittedly ridiculous).
It doesn't seem set up to me as a Hallmark moment. The Dad said in the article his son just wants to do what other kids are doing, so they got him involved, and recorded his match, like any parent would record of photo their kids, then he put on FB and it took off from there (this is the internet, that's how these things work). I have to imagine I'd encourage this kind of thing myself, especially something with a team atmosphere as I can only imagine the kid doesn't often get opportunities to experience something like that.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Azatdawn View PostVery weird responses, mostly. I feel like the time I'd spend on long replies can be spent in a better way, which is what I'll do. Guess I have a different view on this.
Right now, I think everyone has a good point while ignoring the other side. Maybe it has to do with working with people in this situation and noticing the WEIRD hypocrisy, that really isn't hypocritical, that happens.
Comment
-
Originally posted by AKRhino View PostInteresting responses to this thread. I myself, cannot imagine, were I in the position of having a child of similar abilities, NOT allowing my kid to do this, if it's something he wanted to try. You all telling me if you had a kid with those abilities asking to try, and telling you he wants to try wrestling, and you'd look him in the eyes and say "sorry, you can't do that, you're not able to do that." Do you punish your able bodied children if they don't win the little league game too? At the age of 12 some schools don't even let sports teams win or lose (which is admittedly ridiculous).
It doesn't seem set up to me as a Hallmark moment. The Dad said in the article his son just wants to do what other kids are doing, so they got him involved, and recorded his match, like any parent would record of photo their kids, then he put on FB and it took off from there (this is the internet, that's how these things work). I have to imagine I'd encourage this kind of thing myself, especially something with a team atmosphere as I can only imagine the kid doesn't often get opportunities to experience something like that.
Parents of disabled or able bodied kids should encourage them without putting them into impossible situations or making a mockery of them. Abandoning reality in an effort to satisfy your child or make yourself feel better is not good parenting.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Azatdawn View PostYeah, which is why I've decided that instead of getting really emotional over something I actually care about I'll just move on. So yeah.
Show me where someone said he shouldn't wrestle, he should be confined to his lot in life and that HE WAS AN ASSHOLE for trying. I see a bunch of shit given to the adults for creating a spectacle. I don't fully agree, but I can see and understand that argument.
What I saw was people QUESTION the motivation, say the wouldn't let THEIR kid lose and not allow their kid to participate in this type of match. That is completely different than using the Special Olympics, where EVERYONE would be bitching if Usain Bolt entered, as a crutch to compare two different situations.
Comment
-
If the kid wanted to do this then fine, he's been dealt a crappy hand and it makes others feel good about helping him. 13 year olds are well aware when they're being patronized and put on display though, and they hate it. In his place, I'd feel closer to Devil's opinion: that this is not a wrestling match and I'm being made into a charity display. But that's just me and if this kid got something out of it, great for everyone.
Also, h...wait a minute, let me look something up...
OMG, it turns out that WRESTLING may sometimes be STAGED!!!
Comment
-
Originally posted by It is Fake View PostLOL@YOU. Yes, I see hypocrisy at times, not my fault you have blinders on. There are many things "I actually care about" that contain a form of weird hypocrisy.
Show me where someone said he shouldn't wrestle, he should be confined to his lot in life and that HE WAS AN ASSHOLE for trying. I see a bunch of shit given to the adults for creating a spectacle. I don't fully agree, but I can see and understand that argument.
What I saw was people QUESTION the motivation, say the wouldn't let THEIR kid lose and not allow their kid to participate in this type of match. That is completely different than using the Special Olympics, where EVERYONE would be bitching if Usain Bolt entered, as a crutch to compare two different situations.
Right now, I just believe that making a big argument out of this won't do much. I disagree with some people on this and vice versa. That's alright. I don't think there's much to be argued. Different views on this. Fine with me.
I might feel like explaining myself a little better tomorrow sans whiskey. Don't count on it, though (because I'm sure many people will care).
Comment
-
My $.02 comes from Kurt, a tough Okie LEO (last job was children's sex slavery Judge's task force for Northern CO) rancher / camp director. He used his high country spread for handicapped kids for decades, until insurance and labor got too much. We use his place for http://mountainfriendscamp.org/. Kurt talked to me one night about getting hadicapped kids on horses, canoes, river rafting, and even water skiing. He said the payoff was seeing the kid's lives change from one good experience and knowing that he'd made a big difference. Who cares if it's not "real" water skiing and that the kid is propped up on a sled?"Preparing mentally, the most important thing is, if you aren't doing it for the love of it, then don't do it." - Benny Urquidez
Comment
-
Dang. Y'all are some heartless mofos saying this kid can't participate.
Hasn't he gotten enough of a raw deal in life? Y'all want to take away some exibition fun and a great opportunity for the other kid to show some real heart?
Yeah, I said it. The boy who rolled with him just showed a great deal of compassion and sportsmanship. He knew it wasn't a "competition". He saw it for what it was. A brief chance for the CP kid to experience normality. Just for a couple of seconds. The kid can't wrestle. He'll never get to be a wrestler. This short exibition roll was a way to include him in something that nature litteraly cheated him out of.
Y'all are some messed up, social darwinist Nazis if you really think this shouldn't have happened. It was big karma points for the healthy boy and a unique positive experience for the crippled boy.
That's all that needs to be taken away from this.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mr. Machette View PostDang. Y'all are some heartless mofos saying this kid can't participate.
Hasn't he gotten enough of a raw deal in life? Y'all want to take away some exibition fun and a great opportunity for the other kid to show some real heart?
Yeah, I said it. The boy who rolled with him just showed a great deal of compassion and sportsmanship. He knew it wasn't a "competition". He saw it for what it was. A brief chance for the CP kid to experience normality. Just for a couple of seconds. The kid can't wrestle. He'll never get to be a wrestler. This short exibition roll was a way to include him in something that nature litteraly cheated him out of.
Y'all are some messed up, social darwinist Nazis if you really think this shouldn't have happened. It was big karma points for the healthy boy and a unique positive experience for the crippled boy.
That's all that needs to be taken away from this.
Again where did anyone say HE SHOULD NOT PARTICIPATE? I see two people attacking the motivation of the match and one person saying "not my child..."
Comment
Collapse
Edit this module to specify a template to display.
Comment