No announcement yet.


  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts


    on a few occasions i have come accross prejudice against YKD, and I was just wondering why?
    i mean, fair enough it's not the most effective art (coz there's no grappling) but generally it's quite a good MA.
    though i suppose all the mcdojangs do tend to leave a bad impression.

    I'll assume you mean TKD? For myself (TKD Blackbelt) I'm not prejudice, it's just that after I started training in other arts, I realized just how "incomplete" I was as a fighter.

    Not that I am ever going to do any hard core competing or anything. And I learned quite a bit from TKD as my base. But, the fancy high kicks were not as strong as the kicks I learned from MT. There was no ground game & I didn't really think I gained much from the forms, besides some balance & a knowledge of stances & hand tech.

    And my dojo isn't really a "McDojo" we have broken away from all Assoc. & have brought in more effective ways of training & teaching, but there is still a lot missing.

    So, not preudice, just wasn't DONE after the TKD..still teach it, but have brought in a better ground fighting & more realistic contact & way of training..I'm going to turn that place into a MMA school

    <img src=icon_smile_blackeye.gif border=0 align=middle> Sam


      TKD will eventually either evolve or fade away, once people start getting over the martial myth.

      As a sport art, it's got merit, simply because the art dictates the rules of engagement. Plus, it does provide a pretty decent foundation if you go on to study other, more practical/fighting focused arts, if for no other reason than you'll be pretty flexible.

      The problem with TKD really IS the fact that there are so many schools out there that it's evolved into more of a business than an art. And when business concerns are given more importance than the interests of furthering the art, it will undoubtedly suffer.

      Right now, Brazillian Jiujitsu is the top martial art one can study at any kind of organized school, and that's because it still has somewhat limited exposure. I'll guarantee you in 10 years, we'll see a BJJ McDojo or two.


        Although McDojangs have given TKD a bad name, there is still, and probably always will be, Muksodo. Military TKD practiced by the Korean armies, it is some serious shit. The only time I ever sparred one of those guys, I was literally beaten to the ground. His legs lashed out like whips, and his foot, ankle, and knee each seemed to have a mind of its own. No fancy, looping kicks, just straight-forward, wildly gyrating attacks coming from more angles than I knew existed. There was no hoppin around, no light attacks, no fakes, just bam, bam, bam, bam, repeated hard strikes.

        I suppose that's why they don't, or can't, teach TKD that way, but if anyone bad mouths the art, send 'em to Korea for a week at the boot camps.


          That's an awful lot of money to spend on someone badmouthing TKD.


            There are already BJJ McDojos. And JKD ones. It's repellent, but even the good arts get diluted by bullshit after a short period.

            What I wonder is what will come next?
            Monkey Ninjas! Attack!


              Most arts start out as good arts. The only problem is that the harder they are to get right, the more quickly they will fall prey to McDojos. Karate, for example, is, to put it lightly, a bit more spiritually complex than Muay Thai. It is somewhat difficult to teach physically, not to mention mentally. Most people simply don't understand it, much less understand how to teach it. Same goes for so many other arts which have the potential to be powerful, but are taught incorrectly.

              So I don't believe it's "even the good arts" getting messed up. Most arts are good arts, some easier to mess up than others.


                That's if you don't understand Muay Thai, it has a hell of a lot of spirituality, just look at all the matches. I would argue that if anything, Muay Thai is more spiritually complex than Karate.


                  Look at the philosophies of the arts. Muay Thai has some very deep spiritual content, but it comes down to get in a ring, beat each other down. Karate? No. What I'm saying is that Karate is a lot harder to teach, because it requires two levels of understanding. The physical technique, and the mental application, whereas Muay Thai is simply the physical application, from which mental discipline is derived.

                  The more complex arts are the first to fall prey to mcdojos. The simpler, more straight-forward arts remain pure, for the most part, but every art has its morons.


                    You don't understand Muay Thai, it's not just the physical application. You can do the physical application without the spiritual in Muay Thai, just as you can in Karate. To get the spiritual in Muay Thai you have to take the extra effort and can't just expect your physical training to get you there, unless you consider getting pounded on a spiritual experience, as some people do.


                      But unlike Karate, Muay Thai does okay as a purely physical thing. You will never be good at Karate the way it's supposed to be done unless you fully understand the mental application. That's why most karateka in this country couldn't hold off Richard Simmons if their lives depended on it. The powerful, solid, and potentially lethal techniques you see in kata won't come naturally, like so many of Muay Thai's. They must be practiced and drilled into your mind and muslces, and applied properly, something which takes a high level of mental/spiritual practice. In case you haven't noticed, most mcdojos don't specialize in intense mental/spiritual practice.

                      There's your problem. Find your own solution.



                      Edit this module to specify a template to display.