Posted On:2/14/2007 10:10am
I tried searching around on the forums, but I couldn’t find a concrete answer, hence the new post. I just purchase a new unfilled Thai heavy bag from Ringside and need some advice on what to fill it with. From what I did find in my search, cloth filling is to soft and completely filling it with sand would make it to hard. Does anyone know what the happy medium is? Maybe 25lbs of sand on the bottom (to keep it steady) and something a little less dense for the rest? I was thinking maybe beans? Anyway, any input you guys have would be great.
Posted On:2/14/2007 10:23am
Style: Dancing the Spears
Beans would probably suck to hit.
The bags at my old gym were filled with scrap cloth and they were pretty solid. (That **** gets compacted after a while)
I have no idea what the bags at my new gym are filled with but whatever it is they kind of hurt me these days when I kick them. As such I don't kick them as much or nearly as hard as I kicked the bags at my old gym and thus they're not doing me much good even if they would theoretically give me shins of stone. (I mean come on, honestly, do I really want a training tool that discourages me from training with it?)
So...call this a vote for cloith filling, macho posturing be damned.
Last edited by Anna Kovacs; 2/14/2007 10:27am at .
and good morning to you too
Posted On:2/14/2007 10:51am
Cloth should be fine really. I've heard of people using sawdust with good results.
My ghetto bag has foam sheets and sand and while it's pretty solid I haven't broken my hand yet.
You can't make people smarter. You can expose them to information, but your responsibility stops there.
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:07am
Thanks guys, this post kind of stems from my inability to obtain scrap cloths. My local Goodwill won't help me out, so maybe I'll give the sawdust idea a try. Anyone else have any experience with using sawdust? How about the 25lbs of sand in the bottom, ya or nay?
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:33am
Yeh i've heard of the sawdust thing to but can't vouch for it, not having tried it.
I don't think i'd bother with the sand.
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:36am
No sand really? A MT gym I trained at put sand in the bottom for the added weight and to keep the swinging down. Wouldn't the bag be too light if it was just filled with wood chips or saw dust?
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:48am
Style: Wing Chun, Hung Gar
fill with alternating layers of cloth and foam.
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:50am
I'd reckon enough saw dust to fill a 6 foot bag would be decently heavy on it's own.
Posted On:2/14/2007 11:59am
Cool, thanks for the advice everyone. I'll let you know how it turns out.
Posted On:2/14/2007 1:22pm
Schuyler, seriously, unless you already have rock hard shins filling it with anything other than foam and cloth will get you hurt.
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info