-
12th level logic wielder
Achievements:- Join Date
- Mar 2007
- Location
- Vancouver, BC
- Posts
- 1,956
- Points
- 3,572


Posted On:
11/15/2011 11:11am
Style: BJJ, judo, rapier--
I.e. a waste of time that could be spent practicing useful techniques, in your best-case scenario of someone who acknowledges the uselessness of the poor technique. Besides, what’s their problem with keeping people interested in effective techniques? Boxing manages to retain practitioners with a famously small repertoire of techniques. Somehow, it seems they don’t ever end up thinking that they’ve exhausted all training possibilities with the jab.
Yes, but in BJJ moves that are presented as “this isn’t for me” tend to be suffixed with “but it actually works in sparring for some people”.Also, not every throw is useful for every person. Due to height, weight etc you wouldn't feel comfortable using every technique. You have to learn it just so you can show it to someone else. I am quite sure that's the same in Judo and BJJ as well.[ petterhaggholm.net | blog | essays ]
[ self defence: general thoughts | bjj: “don’t go to the ground”? ]
“The plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data.” -
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2012
- Posts
- 6
- Points
- 68
Posted On:
1/28/2012 1:05pm
Style: Hapkido--
I'm going to wake up this thread.
I went to Jitsu for about a month and can't decide if I like it or not. Sure, if I wanted to become a mean fighter I'd do MMA, Judo, MT or Boxing, but the fact is that I have a life and I care about my health and my looks. In other words I don't want a broken nose, cauliflower ears, shins busted into mush, varicose veins and blood clots. Surely, it could make me a better fighter but to say that it's better to do nothing than to do Jitsu is just plain stupid. As long as it provides you with decent physical exercise, shows you a bit how the human body works and the ways how you can bend it to gain advantage, you then have slightly higher chances in the streets. And maybe you won't be crippled by the time you reach the age of 50. -
Just waiting for the paperboy.
Achievements:- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Location
- Lolland
- Posts
- 12,494
- Points
- 18,968


Posted On:
1/28/2012 1:09pm--
I'm going to post like you.
I've been banging a blowup doll for about a month and can't decide whether I like it or not.
Sure if I'd wanted real sex I suppose I could go out and meet women.
But im not sure if im up for the rejection and willing to spend money and effort.
It's plain stupid, why bang a real life woman when you can fool around with a plastic doll?
It shows a bit how the female body works, and maybe you won't be bitter and divorced at age 50.
see?
you sorta have a point yet you're still a dumbass. -
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2012
- Posts
- 6
- Points
- 68
Posted On:
1/28/2012 1:16pm -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- UK
- Posts
- 241
- Points
- 1,517

Posted On:
1/28/2012 2:08pm -
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2012
- Posts
- 6
- Points
- 68
Posted On:
1/28/2012 3:02pm -
You have to work the look.
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- Bat Country
- Posts
- 2,801
- Points
- 4,616

Posted On:
1/28/2012 3:04pm -
Style: Aikido / Kali / BJJ--
Jitsu looks to me like what I imagine aikido would have become if it wasn't lucky enough to have been invented by a Japanese Jesus.
All of the hocum, none of the charm.
Plus, I've yet to see a photo of a hot tjf chick. Their equivalent of an Aiki-babe seems to be an open minded guy that can take his teeth out.
If you want to larp (and I do), do aikido. It comes with the whole esotericism, funky costumes, and sturdy lineage. If you want your aikido to look less lothlorien, do judo. At least it'll work.
When life gives you lemons... BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD!!
"what's the best thing about aikido then?"
"To be defeated by your enemies, to be driven by them from the field of battle, and to hear the lamentations of your women." ermghoti -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- Location
- Ireland
- Posts
- 279
- Points
- 609

Posted On:
1/28/2012 3:41pm
Style: Aikido, bits of jits--
I'm not sure if this is wrong enough to be called a falicy, but it's close. Check out the current WTF thread for responses to a similar idea (link).
The priorities in self defense are:
prepare yourself by learning and maintaining relevent skills for the other priorities
don't get into dangerous situations
if you see a situation becoming dangerous, avoid it and leave
if you failed to avoid, evade and leave
if you failed to evade, escape
if you failed in your initial escape, survive change the situation so you can escape
renormalise (address physical, emotional, legal consequences of your escape)
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Heres a few reasons I don't buy into you postion that it's necessarily better than nothing:
The nature of training is to alter your reflexes and body condition. It is very possible that a your new reflexes and body condition will be less competant martially than your condition before training in TJF (or any system for that matter).
There's an implied assumtion that if you do get into a violent encounter your opponent will have no experience in violence. This is dangerous.
The line of thinking that you can train for self defence without pressure testing is a line often brought up by those who are least able to defend themselves (I don't know about the quality of TJF, just going on your statement and what I've read of the thread).
Running or rugby would be better for self defence than martial arts that do not produce provable skill against resisting opponents (I include aikido in this before anyone starts talking about pots and kettles).



Reply With Quote












Senior Member
Posted On:
11/15/2011 7:44am
Style: Judo