I Challenge Chuck Hardin AKA Cy Q Faunce

[Uglybugly]

Don't name people. I mean we are posting really weird stuff to weird people.. It is not nice to name people unless they want to be named.

[Cy Q. Faunce]

So, Chuck's investigating a friend of WW's, and no WW is challenging Chuckyfaunce?

Well, he claims a different basis. If he can demonstrate that I made some claims of martial arts expertise, rather than a lack thereof, that's one thing. If he's pulling a Ralph Calvillo and trying to suppress by force what he can't deal with by facts, I'm not sure I care to indulge that.

[baby_cart]

Ah, so you have no basis for these allegations of exaggerating my martial arts rank, and want to construct a pretend basis on which to fight?

Answer mine and I'll answer yours.

wait a minute, how does this works?

OP starts a question.
target of topic raises a counter question.
OP restates his question.
target of topic asks for quid pro quo.

now which of the questions should be answered FIRST?

guys I am not familiar with your gong sau/challenge system. I am asking for clarification.

[Cy Q. Faunce]

Don't name people. I mean we are posting really weird stuff to weird people.. It is not nice to name people unless they want to be named.

I appreciate your concern, but my name is on all of my investigations. It's no secret.

[helmutlvx]

wait a minute, how does this works?

OP starts a question.
target of topic raises a counter question.
OP restates his question.
target of topic asks for quid pro quo.

now which of the questions should be answered FIRST?

guys I am not familiar with your gong sau/challenge system. I am asking for clarification.

Shut up and watch the fireworks.

[Matt Phillips]

Here is my complete training history:

1994 JKD/BJJ at Progressive Fighting Systems in Waltham MA
1995 JKD/WCD with Kelly Worden at Natural Spirit International in Tacoma WA (JKD) and James DeMile's WCD Kwoon in Seattle WA
1996 --
1997 San Shou at the Boston Kung Fu Tai Chi Institute with Jason Yee and the Boston San Shou Team
1998 San Shou/MT Boston San Shou and Mark (last name escapes me) who taught out of Somerville Aerobics and Fitness. As of 2004-5 he was an assistant coach at Sityodtong.
1999 MT with the same Mark. Phil Nurse would know his full name, and I had a seminar with Phil that year.
2000 a bit more San Shou (Back to Boston San SHou but only for the weekend conditioning classes)
2001 " "
.
.
.

2008 Boxing At Redline Fightsports plus some throwdowns
2009 " "

Your turn sweetie

[sambosteve]

I think you're lying about your motivations, but let's see you demonstrate your claim first.

In all honesty, Matt's motivations are not relevant to a challenge. You guys have a beef with each other and he is challenging you. You can say yes or no. It is that simple. All this other stuff (Arce, who's lying, etc), while definitely interesting, is really a distraction from the issue at hand...a challenge.

Can someone clearly state the GS rules again?

[Cy Q. Faunce]

Let's see your proof first.

You're not a very good investigator when it comes down to it, are you? This is probably why I had to do your Morton writeup, and why you were never going to produce the Blythe writeup.

[Cy Q. Faunce]

In all honesty, Matt's motivations are not relevant to a challenge.

I've already said why they are relevant.

[Matt Phillips]

So, Chuck's investigating a friend of WW's, and now WW is challenging Chuckyfaunce?

So is this just another advocate of an investigation subject trying to discredit an investigator by challenging them to a fight?

I like Chuck, I like WW. I don't like disingenuous challenges.

Completely off base. Go read my posting on the Arce MABS thread and form your own opinion. This is the last word I'm going to say on the subject: If Arce has said anything that is untrue I want it to come out.

Now, Chuck: What is your fucking rank and where do you fucking train?

And name a date why don't you?