-
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Apr 2010
- Location
- Willow Grove PA
- Posts
- 172
- Points
- 1,528

Posted On:
4/13/2010 3:06pm -
Senior Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Sep 2005
- Location
- Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
- Posts
- 1,783
- Points
- 3,488

Posted On:
4/13/2010 3:27pm -
Yours truly
Achievements:- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Location
- Tampa Bay Area
- Posts
- 1,970
- Points
- 2,932




Posted On:
4/13/2010 11:05pm

PDS Rifles Style: Univ. Florida Kickboxing--
Seriously? 10? 10 for aliveness when you stated sparring is downplayed? 10 for striking instruction? You must have quite a track record.
-
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2009
- Posts
- 302
- Points
- 2,137


Posted On:
4/14/2010 12:58am -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Location
- illinois
- Posts
- 130
- Points
- 1,751

Posted On:
4/14/2010 10:39am -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Posts
- 90
- Points
- 122

Posted On:
4/14/2010 11:50am -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Posts
- 496
- Points
- 744

Posted On:
4/15/2010 7:56am
Style: BJJ 'n stuff--
I do IKMF Krav Maga with an instructor who does a lot of competitive cross training. While the level of aliveness is very high compared to regular MA it wouldnt be as high as say MT or BJJ when starting out. Reason, you have to master some of the techniques and methods (P1, P2 level) before you are allowed to start bashing your training partners in full contact sparring/grappling.
So, in fairness given the three levels of training in civilian Krav (Practitioner, Graduate and Expert) I would rate a very good KM gym with a maximum of the following:
Practitioner: 5
Graduate: 7
Expert: 9 (or 10 if you go to Israel for the seminars)
Weapons instruction is something similar, Practioner is more about not getting stabbed or smashed over the head with a bat - sure you are encouraged to take weapons off people as use them but that is not the same as say training bojutsu/kali/kenjutsu (insert pure weapons art).
Again, I would rate Weapons Instruction from the best civilian KM gyms dependent on level as follows:
Practitioner: 3 (remember this is for using weapons not about how not to get stabbed)
Graduate: 5/6
Expert: 8/9
I'm still Practitioner level but I've got about 20 years behind me in other styles and I've been to some good seminars with some of Expert level guys over from Israel. I'm all for KM but I think you need to review the figures as a 10 for aliveness equates to training at Bas Rutens MMA Academy.Last edited by Prince Vlad; 4/15/2010 7:59am at .
-
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Apr 2010
- Location
- Kanaduh
- Posts
- 47
- Points
- 166
Posted On:
4/15/2010 10:55pm -
--
That's fine in Atmosphere, Student teacher ratio and such.
Not with the technical specific ratings.
Mot in striking. KM wouldn't get a 10, according to the current bullshido system, unless HIS STUDENTS were competing in events like K-1, UFC, KOTC, or WBA, WBC etc etc etc to receive a 10.Expert: 9 (or 10 if you go to Israel for the seminars)
No, an instructor cross training then teaching his students isn't the same.
An 8 would be questionable unless, the KM students are competing on a regular basis.
Note it isn't the teacher it is the students that make the rating important.
Yes, we are talking about tweaks and clarifications. I Do not know when they will occur if they do.8-9: Pressure-tested, full range striking and proven success in limited restriction, top level competitions or high level self defense situations.
10: Superior excellence including A-level competitors/instructorsThe hood mentality is crippling disease, that attacks your nervous system. It makes you nervous of the system. Gangsters and hood rats are especially susceptible to this growth stunting mentality. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. --Keith David--Ice Cube
All I got is genes and chromosomes
Consider me Black to the bone
All I want is peace and love
On this planet (Ain't that how God planned it?) --P.E.



Reply With Quote











Registered Member
Posted On:
4/13/2010 12:14pm
Style: Judo super noob
Atlantic Krav Maga under Kevin Mack