The Hugh Knight sucks Thread.

[lklawson]

Hm.. according to the urban-dictionary article you linked, his guess at what "body nazi" could be referring to fits quite well. So whats your point?

The point is that you misunderstood the term and argued against something that I wasn't saying.

Peace favor your sword,
Kirk

[lklawson]

No cigar. I suspect you are struggling to form a cogent counter argument here (understandable, since trying to argue that physical fitness isn't a factor in fighting effectiveness is a logic dead end).

No cigar since I wasn't arguing that at all. Perhaps you should review what I wrote.

Peace favor your sword,
Kirk

[kwan_dao]

The point is that you misunderstood the term and argued against something that I wasn't saying.

Peace favor your sword,
Kirk

I did? Funny how I would not remember doing so.

On the other hand, WMAcynic was arguing with you. He did understand the term. He tried to guess what "body nazi" might refer to and his guess fits the description in the urban dictionary just perfectly.

I am really sorry to say this, but maybe you should start to

a) read posts entirely and try not to mix up different posters (which should not be too hard with only two or three other participants)
b) try to understand what was written
c) read the sources you use and link to
d) try to make sense in your posts


I know you as a well reasoned and intelligent regular poster on this board. What happened?

[WMA Cynic]

No cigar since I wasn't arguing that at all.

Then what are you arguing? How about you spell it out loud and clear, in place of these elusive one or two line responses that clarify nothing. That way we can have a productive discussion with some actual substance.

Perhaps you should review what I wrote.

When multiple, independent readers are having similar troubles understanding the 'real' point behind your posts, the problem might not lie with the ability of the readers. How about you review what you wrote too.

[lklawson]

I know you as a well reasoned and intelligent regular poster on this board. What happened?

Absolutely nothing.

[lklawson]

Then what are you arguing? How about you spell it out loud and clear,.

What, again? OK, one last time, with feeling: Just because someone is "fat" doesn't mean he is not a "serious martial artist."

Everything else I've asserted in this thread arises as consequences of that statement.