Thread: Judo, Aikido or Krav Maga ?
1/28/2004 9:05am, #51
Adam West and Burt Ward couldn't pull of the hakama, though . . .
"Holy hot-pink hakamas, Batman!"
1/28/2004 12:20pm, #52
1/28/2004 4:33pm, #53
- Join Date
- Oct 2003
Sorry folks but I get real frustrated when I see people who say since x %of attackers carry guns and x % carry knives and x % percent are multiple attackers then when it comes to fighting on the street forget MAs and just carry a gun, tazer, nuclear bombs whatever. So my response to that is that you should stop criticizing mcdojo's and take up ballet because it is all just exercise apparently. I have been in more scraps than I should have because when I was young I was to bullheaded to back down, but I learned that well practiced technqiues used with force and a determination to injure will go an awfullly long ways. Expect to get hit, expect to bleed, expect to be so sick from the blows you want to vomit afterwards, but people go down when you hit them even if they are big self proclaimed tough guys. No system whether it is bjj,TKD,Krav Maga, SCARS, etc is going to work if you arent willing to take it as well as dish it out, but if your neck is on the line they all can work if you are smart and determined to win. Sorry for the rant but sometimes these defeatist attitudes really piss me off. I would rather die fighting rather than just raising my hands in surrender.
5/15/2005 2:49pm, #54
- Join Date
- May 2005
:biggrin:Originally Posted by Neuro
Krav Maga or Magda, as this is a true self defence, combat art and not a martial art.
5/15/2005 3:51pm, #55
- Join Date
- Aug 2004
At the risk of sounding redundant...judo.
5/15/2005 4:28pm, #56
There's one BJJ stylist who frequently taps me out who also takes Krav. I don't know how much of what he uses is Krav, since everything I see him do looks like BJJ, but apparently it might have some saving graces. Personally, I've never seen any Krav demonstration that didn't look somehow ridiculous.
Also, I notice that all the people who have told me that Judo and BJJ are competition and not self defense arts have been in considerably less self-defense scenarios than I have. And I've only been in five where I felt I could have been killed or seriously injured had I acted incorrectly. The funny thing is, in every occassion where I look back and felt I did the right thing to get myself out of the situation I have acted in a way that all "self-defense" styles advise against. I've pulled guard to shield myself from multiple attackers. I've convinced an armed man that I wasn't worth the trouble by firmly lying to him and telling him I only had seven dollars in my possession. I've kept my focus on one target so his friends would back off rather than trying to keep in a state of continuous movement. And, in all these scenarios I feel I would have been much worse off had I done anything the deadly street arts tell their students to do.
So, in short, Judo.
5/16/2005 9:05am, #57
- Join Date
- Jan 2005
Since you obvoiusly have a good grappling base, you might want to take krav maga for a while to hone your stand-up/striking skills. I have no idea what what kind of style wado is, but in km you will have very straightforward MT-like striking and kicking plus knee and elbow work. Gun threat and knife work won't hurt either. So I'd say take krav maga for an year or so to get the basics down, and then switch to judo to continue your grappling.
5/16/2005 10:01am, #58
The guy that posted this thread has probably died of old age by now.
The best advice on this thread is to go and take a class with each before committing to anything. I'd much rather take an Aikido class with a great instructor than a Judo or Krav Maga class from an assclown.If God carried a gun, it would be a 1911.
Assiduus usus uni rei deditus et ingenium et artem saepe vincit - Cicero
Fortitudine Vincimus - Ernest Shackelton :englishmo
A man who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself. - John Stuart Mill
5/16/2005 10:31am, #59
It will be the link between Karate and BJJ that you already possess.
5/16/2005 10:43am, #60
Holy old threads Batman!Regardless, that doesn't change the fact that kickboxing is commonly known as fighting while grappling simply isn't. - Osiris