-
.
Achievements:- Join Date
- Feb 2003
- Location
- Toronto
- Posts
- 18,495
- Points
- 29,624




Posted On:
5/14/2009 12:43pm--
Cool.
Would you care to add ratings because we all like ratings?Surfing Facebook at work? Spread the good word by adding us on Facebook today! https://www.facebook.com/Bullshido -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Dec 2008
- Location
- SFV
- Posts
- 362
- Points
- 653

Posted On:
5/18/2009 11:37am
Style: Parkour and Judo--
Crap. Thought I had.
I gave it a 7 on the presentation quality, because it uses tons of pictures, but never uses any for what-not-to-do or from different angles. So if you don't get it the first time, or are looking for more technical info, you're stuck.
Gave it a 7 on the technique quality, because the instruction is geared specifically for freestyle karate, with a few "legal in the orient" moves. Some of the kicks are a little overly-technical/impractical for most practitioners. No knees, elbows, clinchwork, and not a whole lot of combinations. The strongest aspect of the book is for solo training, but some of the info is outdated.
An 8 for instruction because it is pretty straightforward, uses tons-o-pics. Mostly easy to follow, but lacks some detail.
A 6 for difficulty level, because it is geared mostly for beginners. The training won't get you into MMA-champ-fitness, and the technical instruction would be found incomplete.
Overall, a good tool for beginners and a handy reference for advanced players. Not gonna rock any boats tho. -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Little Rock, AR
- Posts
- 263
- Points
- 414

Posted On:
5/19/2009 4:56pm
Style: Inactive--
Very good review! I really consider this more of a time capsule and explanation of continuous Full Contact Karate (more or less extinct now) than something that is a how-to manual for any of the modern kickboxing rulesets. At this point kickboxing wasn't just boxing with kicks but rather Karate men trying to make a realistic continuous fighting art. The "judo throws", backfists, forearms, knees, elbows and "lacking" clinch amongst other things was pretty much what made it IMO karate and not kickboxing, and certainly not inferior. Around the time the book came out karate was turning into what we now know of as kickboxing. Even his video series from the mid-80's is very different from this.
Is some of the physical training outdated? Yes. (But also some of the more "unusual" exercises really should be seen more IMO) Are the techniques outdated? I really wouldnt consider them to be outdated, just of a different mindset. -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Dec 2008
- Location
- SFV
- Posts
- 362
- Points
- 653

Posted On:
5/19/2009 5:17pm
Style: Parkour and Judo--
I don't disagree with what you're saying. It is geared specifically for early-era full-contact karate. However, I was looking at it from the perspective of an instructional piece, so my review reflected that.
You're dead-on about the exercises (even the partner jumping jacks, I will defer to Urquidez's greater knowledge). To work through the first chapter in an hour will work you, for sure.
All in all, I see it as an excellent book, and I refer to it regularly. But even though I'm just a noob, I feel that its information is incomplete for today's kickboxing circuits. Great tool for beginners; handy reference for advanced players. -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- Denver Co.
- Posts
- 284

Posted On:
5/19/2009 5:39pm -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Sep 2007
- Location
- Morehead Ky
- Posts
- 441




Posted On:
9/09/2009 8:44am
Style: Catch as Catch Can--
This is a great book! Great combinations, insights to training and fighting philosophy and i would recommend it to anyone looking to take their less than combative karate to a combative level with out learning having to switch to a muay thai school or a kyokoshin school. Not that i wouldn't advise that too. Benny let kick boxing world know that, karate can **** you up too if you train it right!
I cant suggest this book enough.



Reply With Quote














Registered Member
Posted On:
5/13/2009 2:31am
Style: Parkour and Judo
Training and Fighting Skills by Benny "the Jet" Urquidez