3/13/2009 6:43am, #71
Two questions that always come up first when a couple of BJJers meet:
Where do you train?
Who do you train under?
As long as this video nonsense doesn't become a fad with instructors and school owners outside of this small minority, then we can control it, with ridicule and ass kickings on the mat once lineage (or lack thereof) is established.
That being said, an internet petition, with widespread intarwebz forums participation may help out - after all, this **** started on the net, might as well end on the net.
3/13/2009 8:32am, #72
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Alma, MI
Internet testing = bullshit!
Video can be a good reference tool but this is nothing more than a play for some bucks. ($) Which just happens to be a sure sign of mcdojoism! Definitely a blight on the Gracie Academy!
3/13/2009 8:37am, #73
- Join Date
- May 2002
KosherKickboxer has t3h r34l chi sao
In De Janerio, in blackest night,
Luta Livre flees the fight,
Behold Maeda's sacred tights;
Beware my power... Blue Lantern's light!
3/13/2009 9:41am, #74
earlier, there was a court ruling that specifically stated "Rorion "do[es] not have a valid service mark for the name GRACIE JIUJITSU" As I'm neither a lawyer nor have I seen any later details of cases, I'm not sure if that's still true, but would appear that Rorion has been successfully challenged over trademarking GJJ and lost.
Either way, I don't think it matters all that much. To quote myself from the long post on BJJ history:
Carlson Gracie, in a typically forthright interview in 1997 with O Tatame, stated that "My Jiu-Jitsu is completely different from theirs, my technique has nothing to do with "Gracie Jiu-Jitsu". I AM CARLSON GRACIE and that's the way it is in the ring."  Kid Peligro, in a Fightworks Podcast interview, offers a different perspective:To me, its always been just 'jiu-jitsu', because there is not a distinction in Brazil. I grew up just knowing it as 'jiu jitsu' [...] To me its Gracie jiu jitsu and Brazilian jiu jitsu: its all the same thing. We sweep, we choke and we get choked. I say it both ways, it doesn't matter.
Rickson would seem to agree, responding to the question of what he calls his style by saying simply, "I'm Rickson Gracie, I practice jujutsu, and I'm from Brazil. You can think whatever you want. Heh, heh, heh. I'm not too much into names." 
3/13/2009 10:24am, #75
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
Do you get extra points during the grading if you wear the Gracie gi, if you are being thrown onto Gracie mats? After the test if you drink from the Gracie water bottle is that a plus? Pathetic. They really ought to think of changing the name of the "university" to Kevin Trudeau Belt Marketing System.
3/13/2009 10:43am, #76
Although in their defence, the Gracie Combatives DVD set itself is arguably a pretty good deal. $119 for 18 hours of instruction is a lot better than many other sets out there.
E.g., Saulo's excellent Jiu Jitsu Revolution will set you back $150 for around 6 hours. Obviously its not just about quantity, but judging by their free kimura lesson, the quality of Rener and Ryron's instruction looks decent (as far as I can tell: I'm only a blue).
Of course, that doesn't excuse the hefty testing fees: $85 via video, $135 in person. That will really add up given that there is a test for every stripe of every rank, especially as I'd assume that fee will increase exponentially as you go up the ranks too.
I can understand charging for the instructor's time if you aren't already a paying member of their school (unless people training at official schools have to pay extra for testing? That would be especially disreputable), but those fees seem excessive.
3/13/2009 10:43am, #77
I think the last a 'dynasty' was questioned in such a way was the ATT Certification thing from a ways back.
There were heated words from both sides, with the ATT loyalists asking the baying mob to reserve judgment until the scheme had run for a while.
There were assurances that the brand wouldn't be diluted and there wouldn't be any confusion over ATT, ATT certified, AT&T and T&A.
I think there was almost an ill-considered gong sau.
The sky hasn't fallen. The world hasn't ended. Doctor Manhattan's blue penis still... sorry, tangent.
Fast forward to now, and another previously reputable brand using a marketing technique and delivery method that epitomises one of the horsemen of the martial arts Apocalypse.
The main difference seems to be the GJJ guys, so far, haven't defended the move vehemently, seeming to choose a "it doesn't affect me, I have the real GJJ" route.
Also known as the _ing __un defence.
I guess the main question is when can we expect the first GJJ home-study purplebelt asking for a tag?Where there is only a choice between cowardice and violence, I would advise violence.
3/13/2009 10:56am, #78
3/13/2009 11:13am, #79
I have to say this... there is a line in the movie "The Dark Night" that REALLY fits here..
...there will be many jokes, and that's fine, but one really applies.
3/13/2009 12:22pm, #80