Thread: When NOT to grip train?
3/06/2009 11:35am, #1
When NOT to grip train?
This has come up a couple times in the grappling forum and in here.
Many times when newbs post about hands and fingers hurting or their grip giving out in BJJ or Judo people recommend grip training. I tend to really disagree with this for the true beginner. In the beginning of gi grappling training you will be learning how to grip correctly whcih will have a far larger effect on your sustained grip strength than training. Also, most beginners are holding on for dear life and as such have already blasted thier hands and forearms as much as they probably should.
My general feeling is that grip training right in the beginning of Gi grappling is likely to lead to injury and over training. What a true newb needs is to rest their hands and learn the correct grips.
Then after you have some callouses and know you aren't deathgripping everything in sight you could start grip training for additional gains.
What do you guys think?
3/06/2009 11:44am, #2
My experience is that it's a beginner's gripe that naturally goes away within two weeks or, at most, a month. Regular class is plenty of conditioning for grip strength, technique, and callouses for most practitioners. If, after a month or two, they want to have C-clamps for hands, then I would recommend additional grip training. Before that, it's too ripe for overtraining the hand.
3/06/2009 10:41pm, #3
I just started training last year and I think when you start out you need at least one day off when grip training. You also need to follow a strict number of sets / reps. It take longer for tendons to recover and you don't always feel it right away (but you sure do the next day).
So no grip training on the same day as MA training and no grip training the day before or the day after MA training. So if you don't have tree days in a row without MA, don't think about it.
3/06/2009 10:51pm, #4
3/06/2009 11:26pm, #5
I had been doing grip training to strengthen my forearms and the tendons in my hands for striking. Mostly towel pull-ups and work with a heavy grip 100 hand gripper.
I've since started strong lifts 5x5 and lifting put enough stress on my arms that I've stopped doing the towel pull ups. Every now and then I'll use the gripper to make sure I don't regress.
3/07/2009 1:09am, #6
3/07/2009 3:05am, #7
I've done judo for over twenty years and most of that was as a high level competitor. I never did any grip training and never really heard of any of my teammates doing any either. Lots and lots of hard judo will give you the grip you need.
I'd tend to agree that additional grip training in the beginning stages would probably cause more problems than it would fix since you'd likely be adding more work onto hands that are having trouble handling the stress of beginning judo.
3/07/2009 3:22pm, #8
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Muay Thai
I agree whiteshark, especially if the beginner will already be performing grip intensive lifts such as Deads outside class.
3/07/2009 3:53pm, #9
As a rock climber, I would say it is the same situation as grappling. Don't worry about the hands... you should not be holding on for dear life. Work on technique. The magic is in the legs and feet anyway.Anyone who has the power to make you believe absurdities has the power to make you commit injustices.
3/07/2009 4:06pm, #10
Let me put on the black hat then...
Would you tell them not to weight train because they will be using their muscles in Judo and that would be over training? How about body weight exercises?
If grip training leads to injury in Judo, wouldn't the same hold true for any other outside exercise?