Posted On:2/03/2009 9:26pm
Style: BJJ, Boxing
The following is an article written by Jeffrey Hall who has made a formal martial art out of shooting, He awards belts and everything. I have a very negative opinion about this whole handgun martial art concept from the train only the weaver way to the doing handgun kata in a gi crap. I have no problem creating a training organization (to be amoung the hundreds of others) to improve firearms skill but this is ridiculas:
P1 Exclusive: Hojutsu-Ryu, the martial art of shooting
The truth about handgun knockdown power
High performance shooting: The head shot
By Jeffrey Hall
At first glance, the concept of shooting as a “traditional” martial art seems ridiculous. After all, martial arts are steeped in centuries of tradition, mysticism, and superhuman feats of skill; how can shooting a firearm compare with this?
If you consider principles, rather than tools, shooting is clearly a martial art. Stance, balance, focus, execution, and follow-through are the same, whether the hit is from a reverse punch or a pistol. We must master each of these elements of the technique before we can fight effectively.
Jeff Hall (above, left), a retired Alaska State trooper, former soldier, and NRA instructor, is a life-long shooter and martial artist. He can be contacted at www.hojutsu.com.
As to tradition, at what point does learning a physical skill become a tradition? I’m fairly certain that the first warrior to train with a katana was only looking for a tool that would save his life; better swords and effective techniques evolved into the formalized training protocol that became the way of the sword, but it probably developed through trial and error.
Shooting has always been a martial art. Martial, or military, was the primary reason for technological advancement in firearms. We progressed from resin-wrapped bamboo tubes, to iron tubes, through a variety of ignition systems, to the sophisticated weapons of today. However, no amount of technology will ever replace dedicated training with professional instructors, and a lifetime of dedication to the shooting arts.
Firearms were introduced to Japan in the 1530’s by the Portuguese. Although some purists disdained the new weapons, others embraced them. The samurai, after all, were in the war “business”, and the addition of firearms added tactical and strategic advantages to those who used them. In the 1575 Battle of Nagashino, an army of peasant conscripts, armed with firearms, defeated the classically trained and armed army of Takeda Katsuyori. This victory assured the inclusion of the firearm in Japanese military culture.
In typical Japanese fashion, a formalized, structured training discipline soon evolved.
Hojutsu, or “fire art,” is considered a koryu, or old tradition art, predating 1868. It usually translates as “the art of gunnery.” Since most modern shooters think of gunnery as artillery or crew-served weapons, I took the liberty of changing gunnery to “shooting.” Hojutsu-Ryu, then, is the “School of the Art of Shooting.”
In 1999, I was teaching an NRA rifle class in Fairbanks, Alaska. In the evenings, I trained in the dojo of So-Shihan Charles Scott. Master Kyoshi Yamazaki was in town for a clinic, and I invited him to the range during a lunch break. After twenty minutes of training, Master Yamazaki was shooting tiny groups with a 1911 Colt. Master Yamazaki caused my internal light to come on regarding the similarity in firearms and other martial training; I then set out to make modern shooting a recognized martial art.
There were initially three reasons to do so:
• to recognize the years of dedicated training it takes to master firearms,
• to integrate other weapons (hands, feet, sticks, knives) into the warrior’s gear bag, and
• to strive for excellence in firearms training.
A fourth benefit, discipline, soon became apparent – the thought occurred to me that if we can build traditional martial training discipline into a young shooter, maybe we’ll have fewer idiots on the street!
With the help of many great martial artists and shooters, I melded the Modern Technique with traditional Japanese training structure. I didn’t invent anything – I just formalized a concept that many of us have been talking about for years. My early firearms mentors included my father (a DSC and eight Purple Hearts), Jeff Cooper, and Chuck Taylor, with later influence from Clint Smith and Louie Awerbuck, among others. Grandmasters Mark Shuey and Dr. Charles Scott also guided me along this path.
This quest has resulted in induction into the U.S. Martial Arts and Universal Martial Arts Halls of Fame, promotion to tenth dan and grandmaster, and being named “soke,” or founder, of the art. What this means to those of you with no traditional background is that sober, life-long grandmasters agree that shooting is a martial art, and have “blessed” it, and made it legitimate in the martial arts world. As this is written, Hojutsu-Ryu is the only formally recognized shooting art in the world.
In Hojutsu-Ryu, we train in the dojo, in gis, in weapon retention, disarming, punches, kicks, sticks of all kinds, edged weapons, and ground fighting; we adhere to traditional protocol (bowing, meditation, etc.) during dojo sessions. On the range, in normal range clothing, we start with the handgun and progress through shotgun, carbine, revolver, precision rifle, and submachine gun. Each handgun test becomes more difficult, until the sandan (3rd dan) test approaches Chuck Taylor’s Handgun Combat Master test, shooting 98% on three consecutive tests. Standards require that a single miss outside the outer scoring ring is a failure of the entire test – the shooter must begin again. We use the “SJH” or Hojutsu target (you can get these from www.letargets.com). Before beginning training with the carbine, each student must also pass the shodan (1st dan) test with a revolver (how can you call yourself a gun-guy if you can’t run a wheelgun?)
At each level, the student must pass a written test on firearms, an oral test, write an essay on a given subject, master a kata (there are three katas, for first through third dan), and shoot accurately in compressed time frames. The written tests are on the history of the development of firearms – students have to know that the Glock did not arrive by FedEx from God (like the 1911 did!). Our goal is to develop fighters who can win when flat on their backs or 300 meters distant.
A typical seminar will run about four days. Each morning finds us training at the dojo for two hours, practicing weapon disarming and retention, empty-hand techniques, and kata. The remainder of the day is spent at the shooting range, perfecting technique, improving speed and accuracy, and preparing for testing.
Day four is test day. We begin at 0800, at the dojo, for kata (the only subjective portion of the testing). On the range, the shooting portions of testing begin. Three tests must be shot, in a specific order, at ranges from close-contact to fifty meters. Depending on the test, times ranged from 1.1 seconds to 90 seconds. To pass, students must have mastered speed and accuracy: 90 percent is required for shodan (1st degree black), 95 percent for nidan (2nd degree black), 98 percent for sandan (3rd black). Each overtime is penalized from five to ten points, depending on the course. After passing the shooting portions, the students must perform speed reloads, tactical reloads, and clear types one, two, and three malfunctions in compressed timeframes.
Hojutsu-Ryu is not for everyone. It has no appeal to some traditionalists who don’t think firearms belong in martial arts. Shooters with no martial arts background don’t understand the formality of dojo sessions (it is easier to turn a good martial artist into a shooter than vice versa!). You can acquire the same skills with firearms by attending classes at any of the schools I mention at the end of the article, without wearing pajamas and having to bow. Hojutsu is more about mindset than specific technique, but I require the Weaver stance, believing it fits better into an overall fighting system. At some point, technique is less important than principle, but we need to build a solid foundation- the Modern Technique is that foundation. Again, at some point, every martial art becomes an individual art; again, solid basics have to be mastered before free thinking can take place. Some feel the standards are too high (without high standards, what value does anything have? Go buy a black belt certificate on the Internet...).
Since the art began, we’ve had an interesting cross-section of shooters begin training. Some, like Soke-Dai Rod Kuratomi, are dedicated, life long karateka; some are police SWAT officers, some are military. Some are highly advanced in both shooting and in traditional arts and quickly master the skills; others have started a long period of training. In January of 2007, eight Las Vegas Metro firearms instructors hosted a seminar and all eight earned brown belts, including the range sergeant, Rich Fletcher.
For those that are interested, Hojutsu provides one path, of many, to excellence in shooting and in integrated fighting. Hojutsu-Ryu has dojos in Alaska, Texas, Washington, Colorado, Idaho, and California. Classes are taught all over the U.S., and can be arranged at locations anywhere. 2008 will see seminars in Florida, Italy, and elsewhere. Students with no handgun experience should also consider classes from American Small Arms Academy, Gunsite, Thunder Ranch, Yavapai Firearms Academy, ITTS, or Front Sight.
We are all motivated by different things. It may be NRA Distinguished Master, Handgun Combat Master, etc. If six feet of black cotton cloth motivates you to train hard, come join us in Hojutsu-Ryu- the fighting skills you learn just might also save your life.
Last edited by JRT6; 2/03/2009 9:59pm at .
Posted On:2/03/2009 9:33pm
Style: BJJ blue, judo ikkyu
Posted On:2/03/2009 9:50pm
Style: Krav Maga/ Judo noob
Ummm so exactly what are you saying here. I get like 4 messages and i am confused. are you saying your building a martial art? Are you saying shooting is a martial art?
Posted On:2/03/2009 9:53pm
I didn't write the article I just posted it. I have edited my introduction of it to try and clarify what the author is doing. And yes I find the author frequently contradicting himself.
Last edited by JRT6; 2/03/2009 9:56pm at .
Fasten your seat belts, and prepare for lift off
Posted On:2/03/2009 10:35pm
Style: Combat Cuddling
Shoot more post less?
Posted On:2/03/2009 10:46pm
I think the problem with your post, OP, is that you present a long article without any real introduction to the discussion you are hoping to engender. All you say is "I have no problem creating a training organization (to be amoung the hundreds of others) to improve firearms skill but this is ridiculas. (sic)"
Why is it ridiculous? Why should your fellow BS-oka read the article? Most web users, including me, are far too ADHD to bother reading a long block of text without being given a good reason to do so.
Posted On:2/03/2009 11:18pm
Then don't read it. I'm not going to edit and change someone eles's article for bevity. The guy makes his case and I posted my thoughts on it. It's not complicated, he started a martial art where guys wear gi's and do katas with guns. I think that is stupid just on face value. Read the article for the author's argument.
Last edited by JRT6; 2/03/2009 11:26pm at .
Posted On:2/04/2009 10:40pm
Now that you mention it, the gi part is quite odd. Are they kevlar gis? Now that would make some sense!
Posted On:2/04/2009 10:56pm
I'm assuming they wear gi's because of the photo with the article. I posted this on Lightfighter and the IALEFI forums too and the debate so far has been pretty much the author is squared and away and he trains so and so and other personality related rationales. I'm not saying the author is a joke. What I'm saying is if he and a bunch of like minded guys want to train that way great but it is not appropriate for the average cop/ non kumite fighting guy.
Ironically he steeps the system in the Japanese Martial Way when trying to do it in Japan will get low landed in a very martial prison for a long time.
Last edited by JRT6; 2/07/2009 1:19am at .
Posted On:2/06/2009 2:16pm
This was posted before I believe. TMA meets firearms. I think I'll stick to what I know works...
"Intelligence is nothing more than discussing things with others. Limitless wisdom comes of this." - 山本 常朝
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info