11/29/2008 10:46pm, #11
All the seals I trained with (5) take CQB/CQD training very seriously.
Admittedly, HTH is not an aspect of combat they want to be caught
up in, but is often a reality sooner or later.
Those seals I knew didn't trust that the CQB they were taught was
enough, so spent their off hours training on their own, in-between
bbq & brewskis & bikinis!
11/29/2008 10:51pm, #12
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Sao Paulo (BJJ Motherland!)
I call BS on the training in between bikinis, nobody in his right mind would train when he could ****!
11/29/2008 11:34pm, #13Originally Posted by meguyiam
If not, this will be moved to YMAS.
11/30/2008 2:18am, #14
Originally Posted by 2003volusia
- Join Date
- Nov 2005
- Washington State
- BJJ, Unauthorized Judo
11/30/2008 11:30am, #15
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- brazilian JJ
A bunch of the team guys train at my school.. I'll ask them tomorrow night in class if they have ever heard of CQD and if they use it.
As for the comment that they don't train h2h often.. I know that instructors from my school and a few other local schools visit the different teams on a daily basis so I believe that they're training h2h more than people give them credit for.
Disclaimer: I have no first hand knowledge of how often they actually train because I have never been in either of the compounds at Dam Neck or Little Creek. So I'm basing my comments on conversations, and my experience from training/rolling with some of the team guys at my gym 3-4 times a week for the past few years.
Last edited by cjlcjl; 11/30/2008 11:35am at .
11/30/2008 11:47am, #16Originally Posted by c4t5
I have never met a seal "in their right mind" -
those guys are crazy!
11/30/2008 3:22pm, #17
- Join Date
- Nov 2008
- Douglas, Georgia
Well I would not call BS on CQD just yet.
Granted I am new to this forum (this being my 2nd post) but I can say this.
If the SEALs are training in even rudimentary martial arts as part of close quarters defense that is still a lot more than your average insurgent is going to have. This has to be placed in perspective, a person does not need to have a black belt to win a fight, your average person with a little real training has a much better chance against your average person with no training after all.
As to the people who say, "You don't need hand to hand if you have a gun." I have to point out that not every mission is a "kill mission" sometimes they may be asked to capture someone, and in that case, generally, basic hand to hand combat training would likely be enough.
So is CQD "Bullshido" as the original poster asked?
I don't think that we can say that it is. It isn't designed or intended to let a soldier take on a 2nd degree black belt with 23+ years of martial arts experience. It is designed to take down the 18 year old barely literate insurgent who is probably terrified and has never been shot at before.
Without seeing more on the training aside from the short few seconds of footage using the hand to hand techniques we saw I don't think it is possible to make that kind of a call.
11/30/2008 5:58pm, #18
I served my military duty in a company that specialized on "swat operations" and our hand 2 hand combat was silly. We were instructed to hit with open hands among other things.. we trained only on striking and cheap tricks. cheap tricks is the kind you will see at a krav maga/systema seminar. Anyway.. We always had to use grappling when we apprehended "suspects" and we didn't train on that.. however.. we were usually 2-4 on one person. so it wasn't usually any major problems.
I don't know why we emphasized striking. I didn't think much about it. me and everybody else in my platoons role was to obey orders.. so I guess I trained what I was told.
Strange thing.. I have the impression that it is more beneficial too be a strong public speaker when you are in the military than to be good at martial arts.
11/30/2008 6:04pm, #19Originally Posted by HWalsh
I think what you are missing is, people are saying the guns and tactics are more relevant than h2h skill and training. Now, I may be wrong, but if h2h was top notch you wouldn't have as many Military people training off base.
Seriously, why pay for training when you could do it as part of your enlistment?
This is obviously my opinion from my military friends and the Military people posting here.
11/30/2008 6:10pm, #20
Originally Posted by Rancid Pantaloons
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Lord Cholmondeley's Airfield, Hants.