8/10/2008 6:49pm, #11
I sometimes jab with the outside edge my palm. It's not super common for me to do it in sparring or in a fight but I've done it, I mostly practice them on the bag because I have messed up hands and can't really make a good fist unless I wrap my hands with something to make a kind of grip bar so I find alternate ways to hit for situations where I wont be able to wrap my hands.
8/10/2008 6:50pm, #12Originally Posted by OZZ
Well I'm glad to know where I stand :P
8/10/2008 6:57pm, #13Originally Posted by AnnaTrocity
I think you know what I mean, dearie..
Last edited by OZZ; 8/10/2008 7:01pm at ." If one wants to have a friend one must also want to wage war for him: and to wage war one must be capable of being an enemy." - Fr. Nietzsche 'On The Friend' Thus Spake Zarathustra
8/10/2008 8:30pm, #14
It's a valid substitute for a punch. They can be done straight, hook, or uppercut style. Part of what protects your fingers is that you don't always need to hold your hand horizontally like in the picture Annatrocity posted to show proper finger form. You can hold your striking surface vertical (same finger form), which, against some targets/angles, fits in much better (for example, hook to the ribs).
And the answer is no, I would just punch, but I don't think the strike is bullshit. Besides, it's possible I might **** up my knuckles in a fight despite them having decent conditioning, in which case I would switch to palms with that hand, rather than be down one weapon. (Even with two healthy hands, I think the uppercut palm version in particular has some really good uses, but tbh, I practice plain vanilla punches 99% of the time, so I probably wouldn't think to use it in the heat of the moment.)
Anyways, I believe the reason it was originally recommended for women's self-defense classes is because they aren't MAists who actually train regularly, so 1) their knuckles won't be conditioned to take the punishment of punching someone bare knuckle 2) their wrists will be weak and punching technique will be off, so good chance their wrists will buckle and get fucked up. Self-defense courses usually being unhelpful aside, I think that logic is sound.
Edit/P.S. Oh, also, as to why RBSD-types seem to like it, being able to hold your hands in an open, non-offensive (even pseudo-cowardly) posture and then strike out with them right from that position seems like a plus for the types of stuff they do.
Last edited by maofas; 8/10/2008 8:48pm at .
8/10/2008 9:25pm, #15
Originally Posted by OZZ
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
2. open hand with fingers almost open is also a proper hand formation. The fingers folded is mainly Japanese way, fingers open is main Chinese way, both work.
Last edited by ITRY; 8/10/2008 9:27pm at .
8/10/2008 11:10pm, #16
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
Here is a way to use palm fist to the ribs. A is when you are ready. In B he jabs and you deflect with a bong sau then in C you switch to a palm strike to the exposed ribs
8/10/2008 11:21pm, #17
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
In your picture the ribs of Brown are not nearly as exposed as Black's head. Brown can at least retract his right arm. Black is wide open. Plus, why wouldn't Black use his fist to throw the weak strike instead of an open palm to throw the weak strike? (To get back to the point of the thread.)
8/10/2008 11:48pm, #18
If asked, for the sake of discussion (and this is purely hypothetical), to strike an inanimate object like a brick wall as hard as you possibly can, using your hand... would you do so with a closed fist, or with your palm?
Practically speaking, striking a softer target with your fist is, admittedly, likely to do more damage than striking it with the heel of your palm. However, I would suggest that striking a solid surface with your knuckles is more likely to result in an injury to your hand than doing so with your palm. It's really a tradeoff - how much damage do you want your strike to cause vs. how much damage you are potentially willing for your hand to potentially sustain.
8/11/2008 12:18am, #19
It's taking all my self-control to not post something absolutely moronic in response to the Wing Chun stick figures.
8/11/2008 1:53am, #20