-
Gnarly King of Half-Guard
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2005
- Location
- London, UK
- Posts
- 4,135
- Points
- 6,408

Posted On:
4/08/2008 5:27am -
Y SO SRIUS?
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Location
- Black Belt City, Mississippi
- Posts
- 5,516
- Points
- 32,284



Posted On:
4/08/2008 6:47am--
Just because someone trains in two or three arts doesnt mean they are an advocate of cross training.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
You , yourself said that he only took up Karate because he could no longer do Judo. We must also realise that BW first MA's were grappling arts and not stand up ones. Therefore one must make the assumptive leap that BW did NOT believe in cross training. He merely did it due to his unfortunate circumstances.
It helps us if you can stop repeating yourself, repeating yourself.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
Dont you mean kick as sharply, as a TKD practioner?
Of course, you are missing the point. MMA fighters/practitioners dont WANT to punch as cleanly as a boxer or kick as cleanly as a TKDoer...why you ask? Because they are MMA fighters. They train in the many aspects of fighting and not just one style.
Using your logic, boxers dont do kicks as cleanly as an MMA fighter, and TKDoers dont do takedowns as cleanly as a MMA fighter, and neither boxers nor TKDoers grapple as well as a MMA fighter/practitioner.
So all TKDoers and Boxers are sloppy fighters. Right?
MMA fighters styles vary like any MA peoples do. Not all TKD people spar the same. Some MMA fighters dont use high head kicks, some do. It all depends on the persons personal style.
So the comparisons you made arent relevant....much like your point.
I think we all have good enough reading skills to understand what BW was saying.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
I think boxers hanging all over each other after throwing two or three punches is "sloppy". Therefore boxing (nevermind the fact that it is a corrupt sport) has taken combat sports backwards.
Yet we must not dismiss the fact that until 1993 MANY people thought that just learning how to punch or kick was good enough. We all now know that it isnt.
MMA uses techniques that we KNOW work. You cant just rely on one set of skills to win. It takes a combination.
Condescending much?
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
Please post a few things.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
Your fight Organization.
Videos of said KO's showing you using the "Superfoot" kicking style.
Until then you are someone who knows how to use a keyboard. -
Featherweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Apr 2008
- Posts
- 13
- Points
- 706
Posted On:
4/08/2008 8:24am
Style: Tae Kwon Do--
"Just because someone trains in two or three arts doesnt mean they are an advocate of cross training.
You , yourself said that he only took up Karate because he could no longer do Judo. We must also realise that BW first MA's were grappling arts and not stand up ones. Therefore one must make the assumptive leap that BW did NOT believe in cross training. He merely did it due to his unfortunate circumstances."
Does it count if Bill Wallace himself told me he's an advocate of cross-training?
"t helps us if you can stop repeating yourself, repeating yourself.
Dont you mean kick as sharply, as a TKD practioner?"
You got me on that one. I did mean to write "kick" as sharply as a TKD practitioner. But then, even most MMA fighters these guys can't PUNCH as sharply as a TKD practitioner. By this I'm referring to TRUE TKD fighters (not the watered down McDojo ****) who train proper technique, who often have better punches than most MMA fighters.
"Of course, you are missing the point. MMA fighters/practitioners dont WANT to punch as cleanly as a boxer or kick as cleanly as a TKDoer...why you ask? Because they are MMA fighters. They train in the many aspects of fighting and not just one style."
But their basic technique is so r and sloppy that they are not as effective in those areas as they could be. i.e. if they trained punches like a boxer, or kicks like a TKD practitioner, then said MMA fighters could be SO much more effective, and it would make the sport more appealing to audiences.
"Using your logic, boxers dont do kicks as cleanly as an MMA fighter, and TKDoers dont do takedowns as cleanly as a MMA fighter, and neither boxers nor TKDoers grapple as well as a MMA fighter/practitioner.
So all TKDoers and Boxers are sloppy fighters. Right?"
Wrong. Boxers don't do kicks, therefore they can't compare to MMA fighters in that regard. That's why I didn't compare boxers' kicks to MMA fighters' kicks. But both punch, and that's why I compared them against each other. TKD practitioners don't do takedowns in their sport, so therefore they can't be compared in that regard to MMA fighters. But MMA fighters do kick, so both can be compared in that respect. Granted, MMA has produced some quality fighters, but the majority of "professional fighters", in my opinion, are sloppy technicians with some butt ugly techniques.
"MMA fighters styles vary like any MA peoples do. Not all TKD people spar the same. Some MMA fighters dont use high head kicks, some do. It all depends on the persons personal style."
I never said fighters' styles don't vary. Of course they do, I know that. Everyone is unique. But I'm referring to the pro MMA fighters who DO use head kicks - their kicks are **** poor compared to other martial artists from traditional backgrounds who use kicks also. Likewise, the MMA fighters who punch have poor technique compared to a boxer.
I'm not saying MMA fighters shouldn't cross-train. I'm all for that. But they should at least cross train with attention to proper technique. A donkey born in a stable doesn't make it a horse; likewise, a roundhouse kick thrown like a football punt doesn't make it a roundhouse kick.
"I think boxers hanging all over each other after throwing two or three punches is "sloppy". Therefore boxing (nevermind the fact that it is a corrupt sport) has taken combat sports backwards."
Name a fight in MMA history that hasn't ended in a clinch, or on the ground after two or three punches? I didn't mention anything about clinching. I think it's natural for a fight to go to the clinch, as both fighters close the distance. I teach the clinch to my students on a regular basis, even though we are first and foremost a TKD school. What I'm talking about is that the two or three punches thrown by boxers before the clinch are sharper, more effective and much "prettier" (which the audience wants to see) than the two or three punches thrown by MMA fighters, again going back to the point about training proper technique.
If MMA continues to produce fighters with poor, sloppy technique, then it is taking martial arts backwards, not forwards, am I right? If MMA is taking martial arts foward, then surely all the best technicians (punchers, kickers, grapplers, whatever) should be found in MMA? But they are not. The best punchers are found in boxing. The best kickers are found in TKD. The best grapplers are found in BJJ. You won't find the best punchers, kickers or grapplers in MMA. Period.
With regard to the "corruption", with the size of pay cheques in organisations like the UFC, you really think there won't be corruption in that sport at some point? What about the "wannabe UFC" organisations that promote "backyard MMA"? Think they're not corrupt?
Besides, this isn't a debate about the corruption of combat sports. It's about the points made by Bill Wallace in BBM with regard to the negative effect that sloppy, punk-ass MMA fighters (not MMA itself) are having on martial arts as a whole.
If an MMA fighter is successful and humble about it, then I'm all for it. But in truth, most MMA fighters are like, "I'm gonna rip you a new asshole," or "I screwed yo momma with a broken beer bottle last night." I mean, WTF? Where did the humility and courtesy from martial arts go? Looking at the attitudes of these guys, they are NOT martial artists. They're just a bunch of red neck trailer trash brawlers.
"Yet we must not dismiss the fact that until 1993 MANY people thought that just learning how to punch or kick was good enough. We all now know that it isnt."
Never said just learning how to punch or kick was good enough. I've always believed in sparring. Bill Wallace teaches more than just learning how to kick or punch.
"MMA uses techniques that we KNOW work. You cant just rely on one set of skills to win. It takes a combination."
MMA does use technique that work, I know that. But the majority of MMA fighters these days can't get the techniques right. They throw half-assed "lookalike" techniques and land maybe one lucky shot every now and again. This is because they don't train the basics like in traditional MA.
"Condescending much?"
Whatever. Just wanted to let you guys know I actually cross train out of my comfort zonel; I don't just stay in my shiny little dojang and pretend my style can stop a nuclear bomb. Or whatever.
"Until then you are someone who knows how to use a keyboard."
I agree. Until then just tell me to STFU, or whatever. I'll post videos shortly. -
Valiant Monk of Booze & War
Achievements:- Join Date
- Sep 2005
- Location
- Baltimore, MD
- Posts
- 18,246
- Points
- 29,717




Posted On:
4/08/2008 8:34am -
--
Trolling.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
Proof please or GTFO.I've had seven fights in the cage so far, and I've won all of them by head kick KO. Oh, and it was a front leg "Wallace" head kick. Go figure.
Oh and due to trolling we need your legit name and org.Last edited by It is Fake; 4/08/2008 9:13am at .
The hood mentality is crippling disease, that attacks your nervous system. It makes you nervous of the system. Gangsters and hood rats are especially susceptible to this growth stunting mentality. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. --Keith David--Ice Cube
All I got is genes and chromosomes
Consider me Black to the bone
All I want is peace and love
On this planet (Ain't that how God planned it?) --P.E. -
T3h R34l Gangnam Style!
Achievements:- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Location
- Indianapolis, IN
- Posts
- 3,636
- Points
- 7,144




Posted On:
4/08/2008 9:41am -
Featherweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Apr 2008
- Posts
- 13
- Points
- 706
Posted On:
4/08/2008 9:41am -
T3h R34l Gangnam Style!
Achievements:- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Location
- Indianapolis, IN
- Posts
- 3,636
- Points
- 7,144




Posted On:
4/08/2008 9:44am -
--
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
Please stop and rethink your next denial.
Originally Posted by blackburntagb
The hood mentality is crippling disease, that attacks your nervous system. It makes you nervous of the system. Gangsters and hood rats are especially susceptible to this growth stunting mentality. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. The hood is where I'm from, but it's not what I am. --Keith David--Ice Cube
All I got is genes and chromosomes
Consider me Black to the bone
All I want is peace and love
On this planet (Ain't that how God planned it?) --P.E.



Reply With Quote



















Featherweight
Posted On:
4/08/2008 5:14am
Style: Tae Kwon Do