-
Light Heavyweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Mar 2003
- Location
- Boston, MA
- Posts
- 3,796
- Points
- 5,731

Posted On:
8/21/2007 10:02am -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Posts
- 280
- Points
- 862

Posted On:
8/21/2007 10:05am -
Administrator
Achievements:- Join Date
- Feb 2003
- Location
- San Diego
- Posts
- 8,752
- Points
- 15,466


Posted On:
8/21/2007 11:01am -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2005
- Location
- Lisbon-Portugal
- Posts
- 856
- Points
- 6,923

Posted On:
8/21/2007 11:11am
Style: BJJ(blue)--
"Also remember that the closed guard can be a great tool and many attacks and advantages can come from it. Remember to work with it. Too many people use the closed guard to just hold their opponent and stall."
This usage of the closed guard is something you see a LOT of times in bjj/grappling/mma matches. Even the closed guard can be a dynamic thing and it pisses me off when I see some of the guys in my team just laying there, waiting for something to happen! Jeez:viking: -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- May 2007
- Location
- San Jose
- Posts
- 673
- Points
- 3,419

Posted On:
8/21/2007 11:46am
Style: Crappling (BJJ Hiatus)--
Those are good guard tips, I am trying to be more aggressive and actually do something in the guard. My first few months consisted of me pulling a weak guard and then laying on my back like a highschool cheerleader on prom night till I got passed.
Now I am trying for more attacks, sweeps, or just trying to make the guy uncomfortable while I think of my next sequence of moves. -
Featherweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Posts
- 73
- Points
- 1,710

Posted On:
8/22/2007 4:51am -
Light Heavyweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Mar 2003
- Location
- Boston, MA
- Posts
- 3,796
- Points
- 5,731

Posted On:
8/22/2007 9:30am--
At my gym, most things are taught with 5 very basic points for quick references with more explanation under each if necessary. I think this has really helped my game quite a bit. while drilling I can think of the finer points, but when rolling I just need to focus on the 5 most important things.
I have been out for a few weeks but something like this (I should start to take notes in class or see if the instructor has a book):
Side control:
1 - Control Opponents Hips
2 - Close Space (this could be #1 I forget)
3 - Kill Close Side Arm
4 - Kll Far Side Arm
5 - Transition or Attack
And then for each of the 5 main points there might be 3 or so details. We have done this with open guard and side mount at my school and it is a world of difference over the other places I have gone.
It also encourages directed self learning. Once you get the main points, students can ask questions if they get stuck at certain parts. These questions help direct the finer points. For example:
Killing the close arm.
From side control cross control (one arm on each side of your opponent). Bring the arm closest to the head of the opponent to your waist side and your other arm to the waist ofd your opponent (to limit opponent movement/ this is the basic side control hold). Then basically kesa-getame your knee under their arm to limit their ability to move into you.
Once the close arm is killed you move onto the next point. It doens't matter in reality how you get to killing the close arm. No matter what you do, this is still a fundamental part of the side mount game.
When Matt Thornton came to give our seminar, he stressed the importance of fundamentals over techniques. At my school we really focus on the five main points of every position/attack. Then we can decide how to get from point A to point E.
And before somone asks, no, we do not have exactly 5 points for everything. -
Senior Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Feb 2006
- Posts
- 1,154
- Points
- 1,849

Posted On:
8/22/2007 10:40am
Style: BJJ--
While I think there is a lot of useful information in this checklist, the problem I see with it is that much of it can't be done at the same time, or there are contradictory points. Also, there are very generic statements that sound great but really don't offer a lot of concrete advice to lower belts, who are probably your main target audience. Kind of like a fortune cookie approach to grappling.
For example, "you want to get control of your opponents hips, head, and upper body". That's easy to say, harder to do, and offers no advice where to start. I want to control my instructor's hips, head, upper body & sweep him and tap him out with an armbar when he gets back from the Mundials too, but it's probably not going to happen for a few more years. I mean, it's like saying "grappling is all in hip movement". It's true, but BFD and how does it help?
Another example - "always have your legs higher up on your opponents waist, ..." Oh really? True if you're playing rubber guard, but there are tradeoffs to that game - later on you say "When he sits back, try to sit up with him. Remember you always want to be tight". How are you going to accomplish sitting up into your opponent from rubber guard or a high guard? A high guard can leave the opponents hips free. Not saying you can't build a good game out of it, but you need to be aware of that to do it.
Another example - "Always practice your backward rolls. These are very important in getting back to your knees if your opponent stacks you up ". WTF???? How many times have any of you done a backwards roll out of a stack to get to your knees against a resisting opponent who has pressure and control of your legs?
No offense, but the list to me reads more like a lecture from my little sister. I mean, I guess Jason Scully is a legit purple belt under Kurt Pellegrino, so props on that, but I'm just not a big fan of the checklist approach to grappling. Lloyd Irvin has some big huge expensive grappling guide thing too that I wouldn't buy. I mean Mike Fowler under Lloyd didn't get where he is checklisting his way through class - more like 6 days/week training and tournaments. I also am a real prolific note taker, but I think notes mean something to me because I put the mat time in and my notes trigger memories connected to muscle responses - so I can "feel it" too.
I do like the GrapplersGuide.com forums there. I haven't spent a lot of time there, but will probably look over it more - it has the potential for being a decent repository like a bunch of others that are out there. -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Posts
- 280
- Points
- 862

Posted On:
8/22/2007 11:13am
Style: BJJ--
I appreciate the detailed response to the tips....and I do understand where you are coming from...You may be reading into it a bit much though...the tips aren't really mean to flow with each other..they are points that should be done at certain moments...and I guess I should have used more specific details with each point and that is my fault for that.
The list is mainly to give anyone even 1 idea that can help their closed guard game. If I have time maybe I'll rewrite it and clarify more. Also it is just something that I really did for myself personally and then added to it so it can possibly help others.
It's also not meant as an instructional document that is why their aren't specific steps to do. It is meant as a way to give people something to think about. For example with the get control of the hips, head, and upper body part you can accomplish this by:
- Getting Head Control
- Obtaining an Overhook
- Having your legs up high (Which I guess is more torso control because it aids in your opponent having a harder time sitting up)
For the "Your always want to keep your legs up high" part, this is the general rule..When you ride your legs up your opponents back it makes it harder for him to posture.
For "When he sits back, try to sit up with him. Remember you always want to be tight", this is for when your opponent is able to create space and work to posture. When he does make it possilbe for him to sit up, it's a good idea follow him and work to stay tight with him. Because you are working a "closed guard" at the time.
For "Always practice your backward rolls. These are very important in getting back to your knees if your opponent stacks you up", this is a very common and valid way to scramble out of a double stack pass, and even single stack pass at times....It isn't taking in consider your opponent's actual positon or if he has perfect positioning, but it is very valid and I and many other people have used this to get to theknees, scramble away, or reguard.
It's definitely NOT an organized checklist. They are just "tips". If someone uses one and it helps great. If someone uses two and they help great.
Also this is why I posted this in the forums so we can have discussions about it and learn together.
Also I want to apologize to cyrijl because the two concepts we're talking about were different. He was talking about a more organized system then what was posted in this thread. I do still believe you can have a list of things but for a specific situation. This list of "tips" was and is meant for a general position and not a specific situation.
I appreciate yours and everyones coversation about this and all grappling subjects.
Thanks
JasonLast edited by jasculs; 8/22/2007 11:17am at .



Reply With Quote















Registered Member
Posted On:
8/21/2007 9:47am
Style: BJJ
16 Important Tips for Closed Guard