Posted On:1/17/2007 10:29pm
Style: Muay Thai
I was in my car this morning, listening to talk radio, when an interesting commercial came on. It began with some kung fu movie sound effects, followed by a voice-over asking, "Is this what you think of when you think of karate?"
My first thought was, "This can't possibly be a karate dojo advertizing on fucking talk radio, because that would be the most brazenly McDojo thing I've ever heard of." Unfortunately, I was wrong, and it was the most brazenly McDojo thing I'd ever heard of.
And if a karate dojo advertizing on talk radio (I keep hoping that that will magically start to look less ridiculous with repeated typings -- No luck so far) wasn't bad enough, it go worse. Much, much worse. You can listen to it yourself right here. My favorite part is when the announcer says "We don't waste time sparring or chasing trophies," with palpable disgust in his voice. Apparently, the very mention of sparring makes him ill.
I checked out their website when I got home, and my opinion didn't improve. At least they don't seem to have karate birthday parties. That counts for something... Right?
Posted On:1/17/2007 11:06pm
Style: Goju-Ryu, BJJ, MT
If they don't "waste time" sparring, what do they spend it on instead? What exactly is their goal if not to teach people how to become proficient at using the techniques they teach? Perhaps it's all some sort of grand scheme to help the McDojos of the world phase out the party clown in favor of wrist locks and front kicks at kid's birthday parties?
Posted On:1/18/2007 2:42am
Style: S.H.I.T. MMA
Atleast they weren't too expensive. But that is the only thing nice I can say about em.
I'm an optimist, afterall.
Posted On:1/18/2007 3:38am
You too can be like : Sensei Phil Lard(tm)
"The study of Shorin-Ryu Karate also has many other benefits. These include improved balance, concentration, self-confidence, endurance, agility, reflexes, strength, and thinking skills. Historically, the masters of Shorin-Ryu Karate have outlived their peers and practitioners of other martial art styles."
No need for the Ant1-Gr4appl3 or sparring when we're all gonna die first!
Last edited by Red Sauce; 1/18/2007 3:40am at .
Posted On:1/18/2007 5:16am
Style: Grappling & Kickboxing
From their website:
Competition/sparring, to the unknowledgeable, often appear to offer a measure of quality. This why many business-oriented studios emphasize it – It helps sales and makes students feel like they are learning and doing well. While sparring can be a useful training tool for higher ranked students under the right circumstances, emphasis on it, and particularly using sparring competition as a goal of training, has many negative effects which severely limit training quality. Part of what karate training does is teach the body a way to react that is not built-in, or innate. Sparring competition, instead of cultivating a highly effective, non-innate way to react in a self-defense situation, accentuates less effective, mostly innate skills and develops downright dangerous habits for self-defense. These include training only to react when ready, concentrating on only a single opponent, and relying only on punching and kicking or only on grappling depending on the martial arts style. Further, holding competition as the goal often results in teachers, students and the style itself not looking out for, or even harming, the long-term health of the students.
Reading this gives me a headache.:BangHead:
Last edited by Motor; 1/18/2007 5:23am at .
Posted On:1/18/2007 7:05am
Oh dear god...
Defense against weapons
As bad as that list is - it's the AND BEYOND that frightens me most...
Last edited by El-Wood; 1/18/2007 7:08am at .
Posted On:1/18/2007 7:39am
on a brighter note - he does indeed seem to have a real honest to god PhD - how frightening is that...
Posted On:1/18/2007 7:42am
Style: KFM, BJJ, Mantis KF, TKD
"Most of the heads of these “traditional” styles did not experience these higher levels of training in the traditional way. Instead, being the most skilled in an unskilled country, these individuals started teaching as if they were masters." http://www.qualitykarate.com/EWKDifference2.htm
Does this sound a little hypocritical to you? Or are they implying that they too did not experience "training in the traditional way?"
ARGUMENTUM AD LATINUM DICTIONAIRUM
Posted On:1/18/2007 7:53am
Style: Argumenta ad Rem
Fred Villari's McDojos were advertising on "local access"--those dark, dark days before cable.
Showed you what to do if attacked by t3h d34dly overhead plumb blossom sword.
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info