Posted On:11/16/2006 2:08pm
Originally Posted by pittfrog
Forgive me for not posting the name and URL of the school, but my kid still goes there(my wife wants him to continue there). While I think the adult training there sucks, and am not in love with the instructors, they are good with and for my kid. I've read enough Bullshido threads which have turned into real life investigations and online jihads against schools that I'm loathe to open that can of worms on a school my kid still attends.
It's a Kenpo school in Western Pennsylvania, and that's as far as I'll go.
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:09pm
Originally Posted by Boyd
Does no one else notice the convoluted paradigm shift of a Kempo instructor expelling a student for thwarting a wrestler's takedown with a knee strike?
No, I found the humorous as well.
resident sick ****
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:13pm
Style: Being a total psychopath
Doesn't the Muay Thai school have a kid's class?
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:14pm
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:18pm
Originally Posted by Axelton
that wrestler sensei needs to man up and realize that it ultimatley was his fault that the whole thing happened. also it was their idea to not wear gear.
That's a very good point:
1) Collective decision to not where protective gear;
2) Collective decision to allow take downs and groundwork, although completely failing to give any instruction on it;
3) Sounds like WS said "hey, I know how to wrestle, so I should be able to do take downs" to which head instructor replied "sure, that sounds fair, use something that only you know and is not what we teach, to completely own the students who are limited to use only what we teach."
4) Shitty double leg = KTFO or you get sprawled on and get your back taken;
5) WS is indeed a *****.
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:24pm
Originally Posted by pittfrog
This all starts innocently enough: I wanted my 5 year old son to learn a bit of self defense, while also getting fit, and learning all of the stuff that TMAs can teach like discipline, focus, yada yada yada. I take my son to a local EPAK school. The instructors were good with kids, my son liked it, and my wife and I both noticed a difference in my son's concentration and coordination. Good stuff.
As I sit watching my son's class, my thoughts turn increasingly to my own middle-aged, now fat ass. I make some inquiries about adult classes. I start going to the adult classes 4x a week, and the classes have a radical effect on me. I lose 25lbs, and am enjoying the hell out of it. Sparring is no gear, except for mouth pieces and some pretty thin gloves, and includes takedowns and ground stuff (although there is zero instruction in any sort of ground game). Some of the sparring got moderately intense, but it was all in good fun (I thought).
The Kenpo curriculum I could take or leave. The techniques were mostly bullshit(or so it seemed to me--I acknowledge that I am/was a noob); the practicing in the air or on compliant targets did little to make me a better fighter. I also doubted that all but the most basic Kenpo techniques could ever possibly be executed in a real fight, unless your opponent was drugged or sleeping. However, the conditioning and the sparring were fun, and my son was going there (I was having sappy father son krotty dreams) so I stuck with it.
One of the instructors had a wrestling background. When wrestler-sensei would spar with me (I have zero ground fighting/grappling experience) he would go to the ground ASAP. He'd stay in a low stance, shoot for my legs, take me down, and it would be over. I got kind of tired of this, as it just seemed like bullying. I didn't learn anything from getting owned on the ground, without practicing ground techniques.
So, I'm sparring Wrestler-sensei, and he shoots for my legs, for the millionth time. Only this time, he does so at pretty much the same moment as I'm throwing a front kick off my rear leg. I hear a sickening crunch, and this guy goes down to the mat. Essentially, as he was ducking quickly to tie up my legs, his face and the very top of my knee meet at very high speed. There is a ton of blood coming from his forehead. When I see the wound, I see that I caught him right between his eyebrows. He has a nasty 2-3 inch cut right between his eyes, and it looks quite deep. I have a nasty bruise too, right at the very top of my kneecap, but clearly the other guy got the worst of it.
WS collapsed immediately, and went to the ER. I go home, but am so concerned for the guy, that I go to the hospital to see how he is. I meet WSí mother at the hospital: "Hi, nice to meet you. I am the guy who kneed your son in the face and put him here in the hospital." It was easily one of the most uncomfortable introductions in my adult life. I call the school the next morning to find out how the guy is; he has a concussion, and got a bunch of stitches in his face.
When I'm talking to the instructor about the incident, I apologized profusely. I genuinely felt terrible about hurting the guy. I describe what happened to the best of my recollection. The instructor says he wants me to take some time off. No problem, I understand. Honestly I want the time off, as hurting the guy that badly kind of freaked me out.
I call my instructor back after a few days, and it becomes clear over several conversations that my "time off" may be permanent; I may not be able to come back to class at that school. Apparently WS does not feel safe with me. My instructor also brings up incidents in which I have bruised other students in sparring. I remind him of the fat lip, black eye, pinched nerve in my shoulder, bruised ribs, and sore throat that lasted for two weeks after a rear naked choke that I received in sparring. Many of my injuries came at the hands of the schoolís instructors. The lead instructor claimed to have been unaware of any of my injuries. To be fair, I had never complained about any of them, although the fat lip, and black eye should have been pretty obvious.
To make a long story short, my time off stretched to a month. I call regularly, but itís always not the right time yet, WS needs more time to think. I do some research, and find a nearby school that teaches Kali and Muay Thai. I call the instructor of my Kenpo school, and tell him that I want the suspension to be over, as I am going elsewhere for training. The new school teaches me very little BS, and the conditioning portion of the training at the new school is even better. My son continues to go to the Kenpo. Eventually, I meet up with WS when I take my kid to class. I apologize to him, we shake hands, and thatís it. Everybodyís happy.
Looking back though, I'm kind of pissed about the whole thing. While I feel badly about hurting that guy, I essentially think he executed a technique for which he didn't have the right position, and ate my knee for his trouble. While I didn't intentionally knee him (really, I didn't) as a 5 year student of Kenpo and a veteran of many more sparring matches than I, he should have anticipated that his face would be open. While leaving the school was ultimately the best thing for me, the principle of being asked to leave because someone else fucked up annoys the hell out of me.
Anyway, hope you enjoyed the story (itís true). I await your flames.
Hey, don't sweat it. You we're the student. If the instructor is worried about sparring with his students, then he shouldn't be teaching. (Of course I'm not saying every 60-70 year old instructor should be able to spar all his students.) But this one sounds younger, since his mother was at the hospital.
You did that technique (knee to the face) that some grapplers say never works (news to Sakaraba). If he didn't want to be knee'd in the face, he shouldn't have been in that position.
Way too many instructors think they look good beating up or dominating their students. It's chickenshit, and the students learn absolutely nothing from it.
Posted On:11/16/2006 2:28pm
Style: Wing Chun, Hung Gar
Bishop one of the main reasons alot of instructors suck and their students dont learn jack about fighting is indeed what you just said, they want to look good beating up their students. Its one of the main bullshit things going on.
Posted On:11/16/2006 3:09pm
Style: submission grappling
Why is he fussing? Scars are c00l.:laughing7
Posted On:11/16/2006 3:21pm
scars are...conccusions arent... He was still being a prick about the whole thing though
Sexiest Punching Bag Alive
Posted On:11/16/2006 3:43pm
Of course it wouldn't make sense for the instructor to talk to you about being too rough from the very first reported instance. Personally, I dont think anyone has room to bitch when they get hurt learning how to fight. Its like bitching you hit your tumb with a hammer while learning how to build houses.
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info