-
Middleweight
- Join Date
- Feb 2006
- Location
- Staten Island, NYC
- Posts
- 1,421
Posted On:
11/09/2006 1:17pm -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2004
- Location
- Washington
- Posts
- 237
- Points
- 5,304


Posted On:
11/09/2006 1:25pm
Style: Judo--
Originally Posted by Don Gwinn
Hehe. Yeah, I've noticed the dogpile technique too. I think it's probably the most effective technique because (at least in my town) usually fire/LE respond to a medical call as well. However, I'm thinking in certain situations (fire/LE are on another call, there's only two EMTs in a bus, etc) it would be pretty good to have some sort of self-defense training. -
Senior Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Aug 2006
- Location
- Thailand
- Posts
- 2,121
- Points
- 3,336


Posted On:
11/09/2006 2:34pm
Style: Muay Thai n00b--
I think basic wrestling/judo/anything with simple takedowns would be most effective, they're not in it for the fight and a tackle works both in a dogpile and one on one. Besides, knee-to-the-head might not be a great idea for them in most situations I can think of for EMS in "t3h b4ttl3"
-
- Join Date
- Sep 2006
- Posts
- 4
Posted On:
11/09/2006 4:30pm
Style: BJJ--
I've been in EMS for 13 years - 11 as a Paramedic, and 6 on a helicopter - all in a busy system in So Cal. I have only had to scuffle w/ dirtballs a hand full of times. Usually, there are a few Firefighters around and sometimes even a cop or 2; so it's not a problem. However, when you do find yourself alone and when all else fails, you still have your handy "Maglite" which is much more effective than some overly complicated technique. Also, once they are in the back of your rig - 1000cc IV bags don’t leave marks.....
I was more afraid of all the friggin pitbulls that were so common in some of the areas I used to run in while on the ambulance..... Had a few bad run-ins. -
BJJ wins again!
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Virden, IL
- Posts
- 3,571
- Points
- 5,357


Posted On:
11/09/2006 4:30pm--
Yes, if we're being serious, basic grappling and body control are most important. Honestly I think I lift people and move people better with some grappling experience--not people resisting, I'm just a lot less awkward at moving a human body now.
You might be surprised how many EMS patients (especially those suffering acute EtOH poisoning) want to fight. Generally, though, police are on scene when that sort of thing is happening and they handle the enforcement end. On the other hand, sometimes there are too many customers for police to handle by themselves, and EMS/Fire gets involved--but again, that's usually the dogpile.
If they're prescribing some new, revolutionary system then they're probably re-inventing the wheel. If you were a pretty good high-school wrestler or knew some Judo and BJJ you'd be a pretty dominant EMT. :) -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jul 2004
- Location
- Washington
- Posts
- 237
- Points
- 5,304


Posted On:
11/09/2006 6:39pm -
BJJ wins again!
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Virden, IL
- Posts
- 3,571
- Points
- 5,357


Posted On:
11/09/2006 8:07pm--
I've only seen a couple of things, but it doesn't look too bad to me. It looks like it's intended to be like the Defensive Tactics training cops do, which is usually very little actual training time and tends to be a few "tricks" people can learn quickly. His "Ground Defense" is not bad. That's not far from the way I was taught to stand up in vale tudo; kick to keep distance, follow one kick with coming up on hand/foot, swing the other foot through and stand up with base.
He's not suggesting you do some complicated foot sweep or a takedown from your back, just keep the guy at bay and if you need to get up, do it quickly and with a good base. -
Bullshido Wikipedia Delegate
- Join Date
- Sep 2004
- Location
- Chicago
- Posts
- 5,327
Posted On:
11/09/2006 9:12pm -
- Join Date
- Sep 2006
- Posts
- 4
Posted On:
11/10/2006 2:39pm
Style: BJJ--
Or here is one that might cause a fight (beating):
A medic gets woken up at 3 am for a 911 call - "person down". Drives code 3 to the address - fire department arrives at the same time - they walk in, and find a big fat woman who says her tongue won’t stop burning after she ate some spicy beef jerky...... Real story.



Reply With Quote














Senior Member
Posted On:
11/09/2006 1:15pm
Style: Muay Thai n00b