Thread: Is it time?
8/13/2006 10:22pm, #11Originally Posted by bodhistate
Sounds like your idea, while well-intentioned, aims at all schools looking the same, acting the same, and striving for the same thing, which is hardly the case. You'd turn MA into boxing.Knowing is not enough, you must apply...
...Willing is not enough you must do ~Bruce Lee
8/13/2006 11:06pm, #12
Originally Posted by bodhistate
- Join Date
- May 2006
From this point of view, you could look at a school that does forms and other...I'll say 'less-than-realistic' training, but that also encourages hard sparring, good fighting habits, etc. Is this type of school going to pump out world class fighters, no. But so long as this school is directly making its students better fighters, and encourages students who want more to go out and get it, I say fantastic. I should note that I've qualified the outcomes as 'direct' because many might make the case that a more fit student is automatically a better fighter, but the instruction should do more than that.
I should say that I don't necessarily believe that a school needs to train fighters (I mean, I train wushu...I'd never use it to fight, it's an absolute blast and far and away one of the best workouts I've ever had); but if that's what they say they do, then they better do it right.
There is a right and a wrong way to learn to fight. The problem is that most people don't know any better and thus prefer to train the wrong way...so schools have solved that problem by saying the wrong way is in fact the right way and come up with lots of excuses to prove it.
Last edited by Lv1Sierpinski; 8/13/2006 11:11pm at .
8/14/2006 6:19am, #13Originally Posted by bodhistate
How many businesses belong to the BBB? A school belongs and has a review on the Org website. Mabey a scale of 1-10 or a five star rating like this.
John doe's martial arts center:
Score 1-10. 1 being the worst 10 being the highest.
Overal rating 8
Mcdojo traits 3 (charges, teaches children,)
Mcsensei traits 3 (charges, teaches children,)
Student quality 9
Competitive quality 1 (students don't compete)
Club quality 7 (new building)When You absolutely have to hide a body...try Alaska.
8/14/2006 6:41am, #14
- Join Date
- May 2006
I do like the thought of some type of centralized system to give info (of a general nature, like can I drop in if I'm just in town for a week) as well as ratings. It is tough to get rating systems to give an accurate account of a school. I think providing a good breakdown of different areas is the key, make performance indicators very specific. You're also then left with the issue of who rates them...students know the place, but are hardly good objective judges of a school's shortcomings.
8/14/2006 6:59am, #15
Good idea, needs better execution. Building quality? Nyet. Same with kids. Just teaching kids doesn't mean it's a mcdojo. See boxing, wrestling, judo. Same as with adults, the difference is aliveness and competition.
A simple pass/fail would help keep politics and subjective judgements to a minimum. Do you train 'alive'? Then you meet the minimum requirements.
You'd turn MA into boxing.You can't make people smarter. You can expose them to information, but your responsibility stops there.