6/04/2006 4:55am, #41Originally Posted by Judobum
But see the attitude you're giving here is what I'm annoyed at. It wasn't a primarily standing sport according to history. But rules have been added constantly and changed constantly. It has BECOME primarily standing sport, that is right, but that doesn't mean it can't be changed again. I see ippons being awarded from nowhere and I keep thinking that people can't afford to get thrown with a bad throw and then proceed to newaza because the second your forced to the mat the ref calls ippon. And if you actually tumble down there you are stood up after a few seconds. Why bother with newaza at all if the rules stop it before it can run it's course?
And you quickly dismiss it saying that those who want newaza can get their freak on somewhere else. Why? It's Judo man, believe it or not. The brazilians had to learn it from somewhere. But Judo doesn't want it anymore. I have to admit I find it a bit silly. It's like saying it doesn't belong there.
My point of comparison wasn't to say that everything should be the same. It was to mention that the two parts are quite different in strategy and execution. Trying to apply ones rules to the other is difficult, but it has apparently been done. Look at BJJ competitions where noone wants to get the worse position on the ground. The standup is extremely boring because they just run around waiting. And there's no penalty and most aren't good enough standing to overwhelm the other. This is the exact opposite of newaza in Judo. Where the rules make it hard or even pointless to perform for those who can, and just ends up as a boring stalemate for those who can't.
I'm not saying a couple of shits on bullshido should sit down and solve all problems in the world of judo. I just find the attitude and rules destroying a part of Judo. But if they want to give groundfighting up alltogether then that's none of my business.More human than human is our motto.
6/04/2006 7:01am, #42Originally Posted by kosen
6/04/2006 10:17am, #43Originally Posted by fanaticalOriginally Posted by fanatical
The attitude I'm giving is a bit of a reaction to the attitude of "judo rules suck, I'd rule if I had time on the ground" that I'm percieving in a few of the posts. I'm not saying that judo rules are perfect but I am saying that you still can be successful in ne-waza. I'm saying that because I have been. You simply need to adapt your game. Judo rules reward aggressive, from the top attacking in ne-waza with dynamic progression. That's what you need to do to be successfull in competitive sport judo ne-waza.
I'm not sure what you're saying with the "ippons out of nowhere" comment. If you're thrown to the mat on your back with a "bad throw" you'll lose. I don't know what you'd constitute as a bad throw vs. a good throw but either can produce ippons if you land on your back. If you want to do well in judo competitions you need to improve your standing. Ne-waza alone is not sufficient to win, just like standing wouldn't help you much in a BJJ competition. If you want to use your ne-waza in judo comps, practice dragging your opponent down with grips and attacking from the top position. That's where you'll be given the most time and it's not that hard to learn those type of takedowns (with the right teacher to show you of course).
Ne-waza is a part of judo as whole and a part of sport judo. It's just different than BJJ. You can still be very effective with it if you adapt your style appropriately. I have been to the point where when I was 16-17 at regional comps my coach wouldn't let me do ne-waza in my matches with juniors to give me a challenge. There are a few dominiant ne-waza judo players out there, JP Kantin was one in Canada for many years. I believe the Nastula was also a ne-waza specialist at the olympic level.
Originally Posted by fanaticalOriginally Posted by fanatical
Your BJJ standing example isn't that different than what judo ne-waza withuot time limits might be. Given unlimited time on the ground you could have long stalemates as well since judoka don't train ne-waza as hard. You could be on the bottom covering up for a long time if there was no standup and this would turn matches into yawn fests as well. The stand up rule was put in to keep matches at a faster pace and reward aggressive, dynamic styles of judo that are most spectator friendly. Judo is on the verge of losing it's Olympic status so they're scrambling around a bit to keep it visually appealling (colored gis) and exciting for non-judoka. Big throws are more exciting to most non-judoka/BJJers than subs are.
Again, I'm not saying it's right or wrong, that's just how it is. I'd love to see a happy medium with more time for ne-waza but that's not where we're at. It doesn't mean ne-waza is useless or not a part of judo though, you just need to adapt to be successfull.
6/04/2006 11:05am, #44
- Join Date
- Feb 2006
- somewhere you aren't
- judo, boxing, BJJ
I practice Judo, we are a recreational club with a couple of competitive judoka and one guy who does mma. Our instructor has us do groundwork with a progressive mindset, we do not get stood up after five seconds and generally go for three minute rounds on the ground.
My only complaint with judo in general is that about 50% of the throws are worthless. case in point kouci gari, it is redundant and it leaves you open to getting dropped by any mediocor wrestler.
As for competitive clubs they seem to be very hung up on scoring the point and notpreparing for combat, it seems a lot like the way tae kwon do has gone over the years.
6/04/2006 12:48pm, #45
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Porcupine/Hollywood, FL & Parmistan via Elbonia
- creonte on hiatus
Where I go, there is an emphasis on athleticism and on transitioning from a throw whether be ippon or not into newaza with no time limit (unless you get pinned, in which case you have 25 seconds), which I find great. But what I hate balls is that there is still the emphasis on giving the back - I go along with it, but in my mind, I just fucking hate when I'm being told to turn by back to defend myself and avoid being pinned. That's my main gripe, which bothers me a lot, but oh well, when in Rome, do as Romans.Read this for flexibility and injury prevention, this, this and this for supplementation, this on grip conditioning, and this on staph. New: On strenght standards, relationships and structural balance. Shoulder problems? Read this.
My crapuous vlog and my blog of training, stuff and crap. NEW: Me, Mrs. Macho and our newborn baby.
New To Weight Training? Get the StrongLifts 5x5 program and Rippetoe's "Starting Strength, 2nd Ed". Wanna build muscle/gain weight? Check this article. My review on Tactical Nutrition here.
t-nation - Dissecting the deadlift. Anatomy and Muscle Balancing Videos.
The street argument is retarded. BJJ is so much overkill for the street that its ridiculous. Unless you're the idiot that picks a fight with the high school wrestling team, barring knife or gun play, the opponent shouldn't make it past double leg + ground and pound - Osiris
6/04/2006 1:01pm, #46
- Join Date
- Feb 2006
Neil adams, Jimmy Pedro, Pawel Nastula, Flavio Canto
Judo NeWaza experts, Judo newaza really is something between bjj and folkstyle wrestling, in that you're often fishing for the sub but the guys who consistently pull it off do it from the top, and they do it from cracking the turtle.
6/05/2006 6:23am, #47Originally Posted by kipdynamite
that ko uchi gari is the most commonly used throw among the top players. It's also the one of the throws Lloyd Irvin credits with helping him capture the 2004-2005 BJJ World Championship:
It's ashiwaza. It depends on your timing. But the guys who have that timing are obscenely dangerous with their foot sweeps.
Every judo player ends up with a small subset of the available throws that really work for them. Maybe for certain common throws there's no-one in your dojo that's that good with them. But, believe me, somewhere there will be. And almost any decent judo dojo should have someone with a dangerous footsweep game.
6/05/2006 1:41pm, #48Originally Posted by kipdynamite
Dude I use Ko Uchi very effectively. I am not sure how you are doing it but I don't get dropped. I am guessing you are basing this off the extreme right stance that has you jumping in to clip with the right leg and this would just be an invitation for a wrestler to grab a single.
Take a look at Jacare and you will see an extremely good use of Ko Uchi.
Instead of going into an extreme sided stance try pulling your opponent around to the side you are strong. It isn't that a particular technique is weak - it is that you haven't found the application for it.
My Ko Uchi, O Uchi, and Uchi Mata combination is strong as hell. Wrestler or no it finds many victims.