Converter of Virgins
Posted On:1/15/2006 12:13am
Style: H'ung Ga & SPM
Originally Posted by Omar
Besides, with all the smack JFS talks, do you really think he has had a shortage of people "testing" his gongfu?
Hehehehehe ... it has dropped off over the years ... the "testers" that is ... pity that.
That whole "inner door"/"outer door" IS quality controll. Fact is if you could sort out the serious students form the chaff at a glance.....the vast majority of CMA schools would just blow away like so much dust and our rep as a whole would be better for it.
Very good Omar ... you know this thing well.
Posted On:1/15/2006 10:51am
Style: BJJ, Sambo
But at what point does this quality control become part of the problem rather than the solution (kind of like auditors seem to have become part of the problem in the business world nowadays)? Isn't that how lineage wars begin (like in the case of this forum's favorite bashing boy Wing Chun)?
Then again, who am I to question a hundred year old practice? I am certainly not saying this has any effect on the reputation of MAs (as long as there is hard sparring and gong sau). Just one noob's opinion.
Posted On:1/15/2006 11:14am
Originally Posted by Firebrand
But at what point does this quality control become part of the problem rather than the solution ...
Never ... the standards can never be too high as obviously at least one person, the standard bearer, met the standards. 1 head, 2 arms & 2 legs ... just like any one else.
Peeps tend to settle and set the bar too damned low. In "truth" we are all gods that have been lulled to sleep by a near global culture of mediocrity.
Don't believe the hype ... "shooting for the Stars" is NOT some lofty ideal ... merely a temporary way station on the journey to true greatness.
(kind of like auditors seem to have become part of the problem in the business world nowadays)? Isn't that how lineage wars begin (like in the case of this forum's favorite bashing boy Wing Chun)?
Piss poor analogy and way wrong follow on question. You fucking civilian cream puffs use the word "war" far too lightly. The lineage thing is nothing more than politically driven mouth boxing centered on consolidating or obtaining a controlling interest in some specifically badged field. It's bullshit through and through ... if these things were "real" then the matter would be resolved in a handful of days.
The best fighters from lineage "X" would show up and fight the best lineage "Y" had to offer, the outcomes tallied and the lineage winner declared. Instead, it's all smoke & mirrors **** slinging based on who was taught what and by whom. Mindless crap that more often than not has -0- bearing on the target activity proper ... fighting.
Then again, who am I to question a hundred year old practice?
Easy answer: You are a Human Being attempting to walk a MA Path with questions.
I am certainly not saying this has any effect on the reputation of MAs (as long as there is hard sparring and gong sau).
Dude, your use of the term "gong sau" is way wrong ... drop it. The BEAST
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info