View Poll Results: What ever shall I do?
- 131. You may not vote on this poll
Thread: Judo Or Bjj?
1/08/2006 10:09am, #111Originally Posted by I Choke You
But if you're going to get a spot on the Olympic team, you pretty much gotta focus on competition rules. On the plus side, if you train that way, you can pull off the legal techniques better than those who work outside the rules. And what's legal is good enough for self-defense in most cases. So you got 5 choices to sub instead of 3, BFD.
Originally Posted by I Choke You
I certainly wouldn't want to reject the samurai compenent out of hand. Kano was born just at the start of the Meiji Restoration; his teachers still taught the koryu model. And what Kano formalized as part of Kodokan judo includes some of the koryu modes.
I find it worth my time to understand why techniques are performed as specified, to better adapt the concepts, the ways of moving. To ignore the history, because I'm not in feudal Japan, would be silly. I tend to assume Kano was intelligent enough to have good reason to retain some important ideas in the kata, but I don't feel a need to always perform kata exactly as specified.
Judo denies reality as much as BJJ does in its focus. Hence my initial comment that they both suck.
Last edited by dakotajudo; 1/08/2006 11:18am at .
1/08/2006 10:21am, #112
That's pretty reasonable. I understand the desire to understand the history. I like knowing that my style is rooted in Judo, I just like that it's also rooted in Freestyle and Greco-Roman Wrestling, JJJ, Sambo, Kyokushin, Muay Thai, etc.
But still...it irks me that neither of Judo or BJJ is balanced. Judo is an essential part of the complete fighter, but you can learn how to combine it with other parts of fighting at the same time. Same with BJJ, it just bugs me that ANY art that is realistic in one aspect has to lack in some other area, why, WHYYYYYYY!!!???
1/08/2006 10:39am, #113Originally Posted by I Choke You
My preference would be to have a lot of judo, BJJ, wrestling, whatever, tournaments in my area on a regular basis - get a chance to test against specialists in each specific range.
Since we don't have that (the nearest judo tournament held regularly is a good 4 hours away, the occasional BJJ tournament is about the same), but there is an active MMA show only an hour away. Right now I'm focusing on training, and adapting, judo for MMA. (My one MMA competition to date, I pretty much used straight judo).
Other judo clubs do host ne-waza only tournaments; some may even host sport jujutsu-style (limited strikes). A lot of clubs do offer competition rules that differ from the IJF.
A lot of competitive judoka also cross-compete; mostly wrestling, but that's 'cause it's been around longer, and more opportunities for high school and college competition. Quite a few box.
I guess I find it important to distinquish judo (or any other style, for that matter - as others have said in this thread) as a competitive outlet, and judo studied expressly for the martial aspect.
1/08/2006 10:59am, #114
Well, I'm kind of the opinion that there should ONLY be MMA, just different variations.
1/08/2006 11:25am, #115
Originally Posted by I Choke YouRead this for flexibility and injury prevention, this, this and this for supplementation, this on grip conditioning, and this on staph. New: On strenght standards, relationships and structural balance. Shoulder problems? Read this.
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Porcupine/Hollywood, FL & Parmistan via Elbonia
My crapuous vlog and my blog of training, stuff and crap. NEW: Me, Mrs. Macho and our newborn baby.
New To Weight Training? Get the StrongLifts 5x5 program and Rippetoe's "Starting Strength, 2nd Ed". Wanna build muscle/gain weight? Check this article. My review on Tactical Nutrition here.
t-nation - Dissecting the deadlift. Anatomy and Muscle Balancing Videos.
The street argument is retarded. BJJ is so much overkill for the street that its ridiculous. Unless you're the idiot that picks a fight with the high school wrestling team, barring knife or gun play, the opponent shouldn't make it past double leg + ground and pound - Osiris
1/09/2006 4:11am, #116Originally Posted by I Choke You
Huh ? Your way off base with that one.
WHAT THE **** IS WRONG WITH YOU ? Judo and BJJ not balanced ? What are you, a fuckin' idiot ? I've said it how many times now, my Judo club aswell as other decent ones will have a good 50/50 split.
Half the time spent on standup grappling i.e throws and takedowns and the other half of the time spend on groundfighting. If we spend one whole lesson on throws, we spend the next lesson on groundfighting to compensate.
How the **** can you not call Judo balanced ? Its one of the best martial arts you can do and pound for pound offers a great base for grappling full stop. BJJ clubs are starting to work more takedowns into their training by the sounds of it. And thats great. Do you even train ?Hannibal: The sworn enemy of dishonest politicians, source of entertainment on Bullshido and newly appointed Office Linebacker. Terry Tait ain't got **** on me !!!!
1/09/2006 5:42am, #117
How many times have you practiced strikes in Judo? Legbars, heel hooks, neck cranks? No gi?
1/09/2006 6:21am, #118
- Join Date
- Sep 2005
Yes, why martial arts have to efectively cover only some ranges of hand to hand combat and not all of them ?!
I understand pankration has ben around for a lot of time but why isn't this necessity higly reconised ?
1/09/2006 6:36am, #119
A plethora of reasons not really worth discussing on this thread. Judo simply is not a complete system, even for grappling.
1/09/2006 11:58am, #120
Originally Posted by Hannibal
- Join Date
- Jul 2005
- Guelph, Ontario, Canada
I don't think that many martial arts can claim to be balanced, most focus on one thing or another. I think it's up to the individual to cross train in different styles to become balanced.