-
poser
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Lower Hudson Valley / Rochester
- Posts
- 1,987
- Points
- 8,031

Posted On:
7/16/2007 1:55pm -
Ghost of Kawaishi
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 773
- Points
- 1,028

Posted On:
7/16/2007 2:37pm
Style: judo, parenting--
As well, if he does not represent the Kodokan, how come the kata requirements for the Jujitsu system formulated in the 16th century by Chineses Buddhist Nuns(we'll deal with that little bit later) consists of 4 Kodokan katas developed 3-400 years after the development of this style? http://www.jiujitsu.org.au/art_jiujitsu.html
-
Senior Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Apr 2004
- Posts
- 1,046
- Points
- 8,821

Posted On:
7/17/2007 12:41pm -
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- Melbourne, Australia
- Posts
- 1
Posted On:
7/18/2007 6:09am
Style: Jiu-Jitsu--
Cdnronin:
As the web-site says "According to oral tradition, Tai-jitsu Ryu was codified by a group of Chinese Buddhist nuns living in Japan in the 16th Century."
This does not preclude evolution and extension over the following centuries. Kawaishi (along with several other early Kodokan masters) were exponents of various styles of Jiu-Jitsu prior to coming into Kano's stable.
Kawaishi taught various kata. See his still-in-print book "The Seven Katas of Judo". -
Ghost of Kawaishi
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2004
- Location
- Ottawa
- Posts
- 773
- Points
- 1,028

Posted On:
7/18/2007 6:31am
Style: judo, parenting--
Originally Posted by danprager
Although many of the early Kodokan masters did come from various jiu jitsu ryu prior to joining the Kodokan, there is no solid evidence that Kawaishi was one of them. I have 6 of Kawaishi's books. All the kata in his book are from Kodokan judo.
"This does not preclude evolution and extension over the following centuries" That in and of itself is a fair statement. However, it does not answer why all kata requirements are from the Kodokan, with nothing earlier or different to distinguish this "ryu". What was the original name of this school? Tai-jitsu ryu is more than a little generic.



Reply With Quote










Posted On:
7/16/2007 4:12am
Style: Jiu-Jitsu