Shen Lung Yi: A Neijia Mckwoon and then some

**cyrijl** · Posted On: 4/03/2009 4:16pm

I didn't even look at the site but yeah

Instruction by Appointment Only

^^^This is not a good sign

**joecos** · Posted On: 4/03/2009 4:22pm

He has a myspace page. Why would you let your teenage daughters anywhere near this guy?

**Petter** · Posted On: 4/03/2009 4:41pm

Originally Posted by cyrijl

Why are you looking for martial arts for your daughters? That might be a good place to start.

This.

What do you hope your daughters will get out of this? Fitness? Effective self defence training? Fun? Without knowing what you’re trying to achieve, no one can know what course of action is the best.

That said, if you are thinking about self defence, I have set out my opinion at some length here. The short answer would be “No, not this place; make sure they stay out of trouble, arm them if need be, and if you feel they need to learn unarmed self defence, keeping in mind that this should be the last-ditch desperate resort in a self defence situation, sign them up for BJJ or judo.” As a bonus, it’ll probably be a better workout. I think it’d be more fun, too, but obviously that’s completely subjective.

**hungheikwan** · Posted On: 4/03/2009 6:42pm

It's not a stupid question, sir. You are smart to do your research. The previous post is correct about your reasons for finding a school in the first place. Especially if it's for self-defense; all the forms-training in the world won't help you if you "lock up" in a fight-or-flight situation.

**joecos** · Posted On: 4/03/2009 7:03pm

Here is a list of the Judo clubs in PA. If self defense is your primary reason for enrolling your girls in a martial art, find one near you and give it a try. It's generally inexpensive and widely available.

PA JUDO CLUBS

**Glenavy** · Posted On: 4/06/2009 9:33am

Thank you, all! Really. I do appreciate your feedback and honesty.
You brought up good questions for me to consider.... our whole family is very active in many sports. Both my daughters have different reasons for wanting training. But I think it's more about self confidence.

Joe, you OPENED my eyes. I didn't think about myspace! From your response.... this guy is someone we should all warn our daughters and sisters about? THANKS!! and thanks for the list of Judo clubs. I have some research to do. Since this guy was referred by a coworker, can I have more info on the myspace so I can share with others? Several of my coworkers were also considering him.

THANKS AGAIN!!!

**Vorpal** · Posted On: 4/06/2009 9:42am

Originally Posted by Cannon_6

"Celestial Immortal" sounds more like a suicide cult than a martial arts school. For this reason alone, I'd avoid that place.

Why are you in my brain? Needless to say I concur.

**omoplatypus** · Posted On: 4/06/2009 10:40am

went to the site..... um....... that has to be the worst MA school site ever.
sign your daughters up for judo.

i wouldn't worry about your daughters with that guy. now, your SONS on the other hand.........

**Glenavy** · Posted On: 4/06/2009 11:02am

[quote=white_kimbo;2096700]went to the site..... um....... that has to be the worst MA school site ever..... quote]

Very interesting... I didn't know what to look for. All this makes me wonder if he's truly qualified to teach?

**Mor Sao** · Posted On: 4/06/2009 11:35am

The person in question, Ian Prescott. Is still listed on ashida kims ninja site as being a school where you can learn ninjitsu and other things.

I highly doubt that this person is qualified to teach Liu He Ba Fa or anything for that matter.

I wonder if he paid Ashida for some cool rankings in arts that Ashida has nothing to do with, like that guy who bought a MMA cert from Ashida??

I would avoid him.