Posted On:12/17/2014 5:08pm
Style: AMAI TKD
Having been in TKD for 21 years I'm used to having pass/fail rank tests. The academy usually has regular rank tests scattered throughout the year.
I've also been in BJJ for around 6 years. From what I've seen, it is pretty much a "merit" system. You get promoted when the Professor feels you are ready. Maybe there is a test. Maybe you've won some competitions.
There is a local BJJ school in the Twin Cities that holds monthly reviews. The students get together, are paired off by rank/weight, and record the results of their matches. Students doing well earn stripes/belts. I've been playing with this concept, this "point" system in my head.
Does anyone know of a "traditional" school that runs rank advancement like this? Instead of a pass/fail test each belt (and perhaps stripes in a belt) is assigned a point value. Every month a student demonstrates their Forms, One-steps, Self-Defense, Sparring, Board Breaking, etc. to earn points towards promotion.
Posted On:12/18/2014 12:16am
Style: comparison shopping
My dog is cuter and smarter than yours.
Posted On:12/18/2014 10:21am
Style: Kodokan Judo
Originally Posted by Lindz
Yeah, judo point systems get fairly complex in the US. Points for reffing, points for competition (just showing up, and/or winning, the rank of who you beat, how you beat them, etc). Competition track vs non competition...
Falling for Judo since 1980
Posted On:12/18/2014 11:17am
In Canada, you need the points to be able to test. You still have to take the test. Plus we don't do it for mudansha.
Posted On:12/18/2014 8:55pm
Judo. Good catch. Thanks guys.
Articles and Reviews
Tools and Info