Charles Xavier vs eu Darth Sidious
Because I love watching nerds fight (especially Expanded Universe Star Wars fans) I ask you all this question who would win in a battle of the minds
I have a feeling that the old Professor may not be up to the task so lets give him the Mind Gem as well.
Okay, let's get really nerdy.
Young Cloned body walking Xavier?
Older full powered walking Xavier?
Any of those incarnations are psychically better than Dark Jedi mental control without the gem.
Now, do you mean a full on physical and mental battle? Then Sidious.
EU Sidious mind controlled a population of 20 billion without any effort. I know we see a lot of impressive psychic battles out of Professor X but I don't think we see a feat that is comparable to that.
Originally Posted by goodlun
To repel the invasion, Xavier combined his mind with the ones of all the people of the planet in order to give the Z'nox a huge psionic blast. Finally, the aliens had to run away.
Yes, I know, you weren't as up to date on Professor X as you thought. That was done with the entire population of earth, which included non mutants and giving away a portion of his ability to another person.
Professor Xavier went underground from all of his original students, save Jean, to prepare of the invasion of the alien Z'Nox and had the reformed and dying villain, Changeling, posing as him after giving him a portion of his telepathic power.
Take it how you will. Psychic battle I give to PX. Full on battle even with the use of legs, I give to sidious.
Last edited by It is Fake; 5/27/2013 7:39pm at .
It is an impressive feat. I am not up to date on either EU Star Wars or Marvel comics. I do know that both characters have some incredible feats. I was hoping with the nice little nerd population here I would draw out some of the more knowledgeable people on both sides.
Originally Posted by It is Fake
I know Sidious has some really incredible feats of psychic domination. I just am not knowledge enough on the specifics to argue them.
That being said I really would like to hear some of the experts that I know are lurking around here to weigh in before I am convinced one way or the other.
Also some other fun ones to think about
Steve Rogers vs Baki the grappler cage match normal rules 5 5 min rounds
How many Sentials could Voltron handle at one time
Dr Strange vs Zod
Blade vs Alucard(Hellsing anime)
Agree with Fake on the Darth Sidious Vs. Prof. X showdown. Physically, Sidious would dominate Xavier but put to a psychic battle, Prof. X would have him in tears.
I reckon Alucard (with all CARS levels released) would pull Blade apart in a matter of moments. With the control systems in place? Could be anyones fight.
You're assuming that Prof. X doesn't just mind-read Sidious or one of his weaker disciples or a random Jedi and learn to use the force himself.
Sidious' mind was unreadable to all of the Jedi Council including Saesee Tiin whom was a gifted telepath. In fact Sidious's mind was also unreadable to his own master Darth Plagueis.
Originally Posted by Fuzzy
Phoenix force is a cosmic entity that can destroy planets. Sidious needed a Death Star to do the same thing. Professor X shut down the mutants wielding that power. The five wielding the power were trained, by Xavier himself, to be nearly impervious to mind control.
Originally Posted by goodlun
Yes, I used to be a HUGE X-men reader for about 20 odd years. Yes, EVERY X-title.
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO