Thread: Why do YOU think Aikido Sucks??
3/26/2013 12:51pm, #171
3/26/2013 12:51pm, #172
Finally the guy straightened his arm to counter my armlock attempts. Frustrated and worried that someone else was going to kick my ass while I paid attention to him, I went for a waki-getame at full speed.
It broke his arm in an ugly fashion. It also made me sick to my stomach.
Looking back, I know that it was a mistake to try to use the first armlock (the one that Greg's video demos) on someone who was not vulnerable to it. He had no forward momentum when I tried to apply it, so I ended up trying to wrestle his arm into the proper position.
3/26/2013 12:57pm, #173
- Join Date
- Nov 2012
- San Diego
- street paddleboarding
3/26/2013 1:00pm, #174
3/26/2013 10:11pm, #175
(I dont know what the real name is)
Double overhook from behind. And then a sort of single arm through both of theirs.
I should do a vid on that one because if you get it off they are caught and you have a hand free.
Also really good for the handcuffing I would imagine. If they ever let us have handcuffs.
And I am blaming Akido for that too.
Last edited by gregaquaman; 3/26/2013 10:19pm at .Whitsunday Martial Arts Airlie Beach North Queensland.
3/28/2013 12:06pm, #176
- Join Date
- Nov 2008
- JJJ, BJJ, CSW, Kali, JKD
Does Aikido has its place in self-defense? Yes, I think every martial art has something offer. Some Aikido techniques work great in response of certain common attacks i.e. irimi off a wrist pull.
That said, Aikido as an individual art fairs poorly compared to other arts as far self defense goes.
Self-defense techniques should :
1) be easy to learn.
2) allow you to reach your target directly and quickly (straight lines)
3) be easy to execute: In an adrenalized state, the vast majority of people are restricted to gross motor skills and unable to perform complicated techniques.
Yes, 1 and 3 are closely connected
In its pure martial artsy form, Aikido is very technical, hard to learn and require a lot of practice. Not good. They rely on big circular motions and change of levels and speed. Not good. Aikido doesn't rely on gross motor skills but technical ones - very hard to pull off in an adrenalized state, let alone against a resisting attacker. Basically many Aikido techniques are low percentage shots. Not good.
I might incorporate some Aikido in my "ultimate self-defense system" if ever I would try to gather the most effective techniques around (though other arts offer as techniques as effective and easier to execute and learn), but if I had to pick one art, Aikido wouldn't even be close to being in contention.
3/30/2013 2:51am, #177
- Join Date
- Jul 2011
I originally was going to train Aikido. My buddy who trained BJJ suggested I train Judo because of my high interest in throwing people.
So, now, I'm a Judo guy, and a BJJ guy. I've grappled with Aikidoka, and I've done Tachiwaza with Aikidoka.
In my opinion, Akido is actually an advanced art. It's not something you can utilize in and of itself as a base for defense or attack. As it stands now, there's no merit for combat. Now, that said, It is interesting, and an experienced Aki guy can make things slow going for a Judo guy that has restraint.
What I did find usefull was the posture and balance. Aside from that, I felt like I was sparring against a beat down, wet, starving dog.
I think there's potential, and maybe when , "O" recreated Aikido, it might've had more merit, although I suspect, that the rigors of training was what gave the ability for combat. This is where I get confused. This is where I also, decided, training hard, and abusing yourself does nothing for defense other than the ability to take a beating. That's not a bad thing in itself, as all of us as fighters/Martial Artists must face.
It seems to me that, the merits of Aikidodo were founded on the amount of abuse one can take rather than the merits of a safe retreat, or if needed, a controlled submission.
Aikido seems to have more merit if the opponent has a sward, just like some Judo Kata, and most MA's. "Grab my wrist" is a good indication. **** you and your wrist! If you don't have a sword, that ****'s not happening. See?
Another thing, Hippies. Aikido has been misunderstood, and watered down, by, soooo many hippies. It seems it's better to drop 10 hits of LSD and grab a tickle me elmo for defense than all that peace love and hard liquor that seems to surround Akido.
3/31/2013 5:59am, #178
- Join Date
- Jan 2012
I trained aikido for 2 years and liked it. I learned falling and ukemi, I think some disarming, transporting and restraining techniques are useful against an unsuspecting opponent...
But even before reading Bullshido I became dissatisfied with the lack of randori, since I am not a complete idiot, so I stopped.
If I had time, money and the energy I would probably take it for exercising - like yoga or tai chi, but not martial art.
6/01/2013 12:25pm, #179
- Join Date
- Jun 2013
This no-touch Aikido is disgraceful... I wonder what Watanabe was thinking... And what is wrong with his uke?
6/01/2013 2:03pm, #180
Der Auslander won this thread in the third post. As our British friends would say "What the fook are you goin on about mate?""We often joke -- and we really wish it were a joke -- that you will only encounter two basic problems with your 'self-defense' training.
1) That it doesn't work
2) That it does work"