Thread: Youth v.s. Experience
10/10/2012 8:27pm, #1
Youth v.s. Experience
Not the way it's usually discussed.
I'm looking at my registration packet for the 47th Dallas Invitational Judo Championship and I'm trying to decide which division to register for. It looks like the Masters division is divided by age but not experience level, whereas the Seniors have an under brown belt Novice division. So, do I want to register for the 40 - 49 year old Masters division and fight guys my age but who have a lot more experience (i.e. I'm only a yellow belt in Judo) or do I want to fight guys a lot younger than me who are relatively the same experience level?
I'm thinking I'd be better off fighting a 20 year old yellow or green belt than a 49 year old black belt. I'll ask my instructor what he thinks, but I was interested on what others here might opt for.
10/10/2012 8:39pm, #2
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
**** no, that type of **** tournament is bullshit, I've fought 40 year olds at age 13-15 because of this and they kicked my ass, some even have done MA since I've been born. Unless you want to be bull rushed, don't sign up. It wasn't till later I realized this.
point: fight at your rank not your age. There is always going to be a young "ip man" in the group.
10/10/2012 10:53pm, #3"We often joke -- and we really wish it were a joke -- that you will only encounter two basic problems with your 'self-defense' training.
1) That it doesn't work
2) That it does work"
10/11/2012 1:03am, #4
10/11/2012 2:12am, #5
Go with rank, that way when you lose you can blame it on being old
10/11/2012 2:17am, #6
- Join Date
- Aug 2012
Rank all the way. You don't want to deal with the old man strength and experience when you can just deal with younger guys and probably out muscle them.
10/11/2012 3:42am, #7
I'm a smalish guy, so I prefer to go by weight. If I go into kyu I face the possibility of dealing with some guy who is literally twice my size (it's happened) and who has no fucking finesse. This means a 5 minute slog wile I get awkwardly mashed against the mats with a high chance of injury.
At least in the weights, if some guy is going to outclass me, it's going to be on skill which means a nice clean ippon to end the match - leaving me sufficiently intact to fight again some day.
Also with the masters your opponents could be very varied. Outside of a few serious international events, you're going to get everyone from that black-belt who competes every month minimum, and has just had his birthday, to the old guy who's just there to have some fun and show he can still do stuff, to the guy who started late and is a bit confused by the whole thing.
10/11/2012 5:37am, #8
Thanks guys. I was thinking that experience level would be more of a factor than age. Goodlun, is the inverse of your point that if I win all of the younger guys will attribute it to "old man strength." ;-)
The choice I have is to register for male Senior Novice (over 20 years of age and under brown belt) or male Masters in the 40 - 49 year old bracket (i.e. open to anyone in that age bracket regardless of rank). I think Crappler makes a good point with regards to what I won't get out of this tournament if I compete against a bunch of salty dogs who can beat my ass without breaking a sweat.
FWIW, the only other Judo tournament I've competed in had a Masters Novice division, so I was able to fight against of old newbies like myself. However, because the number of competitors for that division was fairly small, they had to match us up into three weight classes roughly evenly divided by numbers, which resulted in my being the smallest guy in my bracket. I think that another benefit to competing in the Seniors Novice rather than the Masters division is that I will be more evenly matched in weight as well as experience, although I am currently at the low end of the 81 kg weight bracket (i.e. my current weight is 165lbs/74.8kilos and the next lower weight class is 73kilos/160.9lbs). This begs the question, since weigh ins are the night before the tournament, should I try and cut five pounds to fight in a lighter weight class?
10/11/2012 8:09am, #9
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
I'm going to slightly go against the grain here. I am 37, weigh 215lbs and currently a green belt. I have the same concerns when I consider playing in a tournament. I have recently been leaning towards playing Masters because the guys are pretty much going to be in the same shape as me and will most likely try to avoid getting hurt as much as me. The truth is, Masters can't beat up their bodies like the young guys can. In my club there is a college kid, 22 yrs old I think. He weighs in at 210lbs and after we do randori sometimes it just hurts.
If you fight novice men you will play people of similar experience but most likely a lot younger. Young guys tend to kill or be killed in tournaments. Another thing to think about is your current weight is 160 and judging from the tournament we just had that is one of the bigger brackets. Meaning more fights and since Dallas is a pretty big event, there will probably be even more. If you fight Masters you will fight guys who are the same age and approximate weight but more experience. However, if they beat you they will beat you with technique and not power.
If you are concerned about injury I would fight Masters. Take your 3 favorite throws and make a plan. If A happens you'll do B. If B happens you'll do C. Stick to your plan. If your plan gets interrupted, break grip, back out and start over.
At our tournament, I run brackets so I get to watch matches from up close. The Masters matches were slower. There wasn't as much jerking around like you see in novice mens. Regardless of what you choose stay loose and have fun.
10/11/2012 10:01am, #10
Thanks. Some very good points, especially with regards to how hard young guys go and the risk of injury. That said, some of the older guys I train with go pretty hard in training, too. The brown and black belts just have an easier time throwing me.