I'd like to ask you all for feedback!...

**fudoshin_ryu** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 12:31pm

Originally Posted by Permalost

Depends on what you mean by feedback.

I supposed that's a viable response. lol

On a side note though. Someone above mentioned there were quite a bit of topics on An Jian Qiu? I tried looking but wasn't able to locate any. Would anyone know of where to find them right off hand? I'm trying to figure out what kind of guy he is, since I don't know him.

***DerAuslander*** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 12:43pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

Ill try.

So for future references...It's best not to post videos and expect feedback on the form?

No, it's best to be honest and not act like a whiney douchebag when people ask you questions.

**doofaloofa** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 12:53pm

OP

Here is a thread where you can post vids of forms

**W. Rabbit** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 12:55pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

On a side note though. Someone above mentioned there were quite a bit of topics on An Jian Qiu? I tried looking but wasn't able to locate any. Would anyone know of where to find them right off hand? I'm trying to figure out what kind of guy he is, since I don't know him.

Videos, not threads. His videos pop up now and then in various sanda threads.

Why not just search for "sanda" and really get the wheel rolling?

Here start with this:

http://www.bullshido.net/forums/show...=118033&page=1

**It is Fake** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 1:13pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

Ill try.

So for future references...It's best not to post videos and expect feedback on the form?

No, it is best to post videos WITH DETAILS of what you are looking for in critiques.
Your OP sucks elephant ass and you received all type of feedback.

**Eddie Hardon** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 1:44pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

As for the name Fudoshin it should mean Immovable Mind (Just thought I'd throw that in since you didn't put the whole term in...thought you didn't know...I could be wrong though.)!

Yes, you are wrong.

**fudoshin_ryu** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 1:48pm

Even if your not a practitioner of the Chinese martial arts! Please leave your feedback of what you thought was 'right' or 'wrong' with my form or techniques!

I thought that, that would have been enough to show that I wanted feedback on my form...but I will try harder next time. Thanks.

Yes, you are wrong.

I was wrong that you didn't know or I was wrong about what the term meant?

**Permalost** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 1:58pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

I thought that, that would have been enough to show that I wanted feedback on my form...but I will try harder next time. Thanks.

-what about your form? You'll need to ask better questions for better answers. I like giving specific questions to specific answers, but "what do you think of this?" will rarely yield good responses.

-by saying "Even if your not a practitioner of the Chinese martial arts", you're working under the narrative that all martial artists are more or less equal and do things that are mostly the same, but really if you're outside of CMA (and Far Eastern MA in general) there's not much to say about the form. If you're from a style that doesn't use forms at all, you may not understand why people even do forms, let alone what the training method is or what the applications of the moves are. If you're from a style that does forms, but in a way that's totally different, that probably won't be too helpful either.

**Eddie Hardon** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 1:59pm

Originally Posted by fudoshin_ryu

I thought that, that would have been enough to show that I wanted feedback on my form...but I will try harder next time. Thanks.

I was wrong that you didn't know or I was wrong about what the term meant?

[oh my word...]

I knew what the term meant.

**It is Fake** · Posted On: 10/03/2012 2:12pm

Originally Posted by Permalost

-by saying "Even if your not a practitioner of the Chinese martial arts", you're working under the narrative that all martial artists are more or less equal and do things that are mostly the same, but really if you're outside of CMA (and Far Eastern MA in general) there's not much to say about the form. If you're from a style that doesn't use forms at all, you may not understand why people even do forms, let alone what the training method is or what the applications of the moves are. If you're from a style that does forms, but in a way that's totally different, that probably won't be too helpful either.

This right here is why your OP was poor.