YouTube Pundit who claims all Martial Artists are really just broken people

**W. Rabbit** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 2:39pm

I wonder what he thinks about people who like Tool...probably has all sorts of terrible theories about that.

This guy is supposed to be a philosopher right? So why is he trying to gather data...leave it to the scientists, bro. Keep ranting on Youtube, right where you belong.

**Permalost** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 2:54pm

Originally Posted by Mr. Machette

Tai Chi, for example, could only be explained by it's practitioners continuing to act out the cycle of abuse they experienced as kids.

**BJMills** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 3:14pm

Originally Posted by Permalost

That right there is a cry to perpetuate violence.

**goodlun** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 4:30pm

This video makes me so ANGRY I think I am going to break his ARM if I ever see him or not cause really I just like to you know lose weight and prolong my life by doing an exercise I enjoy.

**Foolish** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 4:34pm

Originally Posted by Bodhi108

Why would I want to disprove his theory?

He doesn't have a theory, he has a logical fallacy. Even if you accept his data he is assuming or implying that correlation proves causation. There is no need to disprove his statement until he has a reasonable arguement proving it.

Until then he is just an asshole with an opinion.

**It is Fake** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 5:35pm

Originally Posted by Foolish

He doesn't have a theory, he has a logical fallacy. Even if you accept his data he is assuming or implying that correlation proves causation. There is no need to disprove his statement until he has a reasonable arguement proving it.

Until then he is just an asshole with an opinion.

Originally Posted by Bodhi108

Why would I want to disprove his theory?

**CrackFox** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 6:01pm

Originally Posted by Bodhi108

Why would I want to disprove his theory?

Because if you don't, then who will?

**Permalost** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 6:27pm

Originally Posted by BJMills

That right there is a cry to perpetuate violence.

Actually its a cry to Work the Shuttle, which is the modern English translation of the tai chi technique "Fair Lady Works the Shuttle If She Knows What's Good For Her". Its a key move in the Yang style Goddammit Pizza's Not Dinner form.

**Mr. Machette** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 6:57pm

Originally Posted by Permalost

Actually its a cry to Work the Shuttle, which is the modern English translation of the tai chi technique "Fair Lady Works the Shuttle If She Knows What's Good For Her". Its a key move in the Yang style Goddammit Pizza's Not Dinner form.

You just made me blow Squirt soda out my nose.

Wel played sir, well played.

Hmmm, I did a google search for "clapping ,gif" and this is what I got...

Fair nuff!

Originally Posted by Foolish

He doesn't have a theory, he has a logical fallacy. Even if you accept his data he is assuming or implying that correlation proves causation. There is no need to disprove his statement until he has a reasonable arguement proving it.

Until then he is just an asshole with an opinion.

Dang! Well lookit the big brain on Foolish. I see what you did there!

All artfully doging OP's dialectical tractor beam of suck. Hell yeah.

You were all like;

"Yo Hegel! Synthesize THIS!"

**WoodyCorpus** · Posted On: 9/06/2012 7:47pm

I'm probably the only one who fits in his theory. I started martial arts early (age 10) but it didn't helpme against bullies because the biggest one of them all happened to be a brown belt in the judo club I went to. Getting a Kata Guruma from him was a painful weekely experience.
It strengthened me. Pain just doesn't scare me that much anymore.

I got back to MA two years ago. Met an old friend in a bar, but he was there with some new friends of his, members of an extremist right splinter group. When my own political views didn't match theirs **** got violent, and except for some throws and evasive **** I was helpless against striking and such. I walked away scared, but hardly in any pain.

Started kenpo in a club where a few of my friends went. A few guys crosstrain in other arts such as judo, ju-jutsu ( JJJ) and full contact. Good experience for this "broken" man, because when I got into the next scrap I felt calm, I evaded, I took some hits and just remained calm. Broken... Pffff, I know a few girls who got gang raped and weren't broken. Why should I be? Shaken by the harshnes of life? Given. Bent by violence? Was my path ever that straight (non sexual)? Broken? For the love of whatever! If most people in MA are broken people then they are the most balanced "broken" beings I have ever seen. Let this guy have his playtime on the toobs, his theory is shady at best.

Ranting mode is over. Sorry.