Generalising a bit, someone like a BJJ instructor basically sells a different kind of product from, say, a Wing Chun instructor. The BJJ instructor is selling objectively quantifiable training, and his product is evaluated in terms of how his students fare at BJJ tournaments. The Wing Chun instructor is selling training in an art with no objective endpoint, so his product is evaluated strictly in terms of how much he can convince people it is subjectively worth. Of course the latter kind of product is going to be subject to more BS; there’s no objective quality control! To make matters worse, improving training will do nothing to bring business success when fighting skills aren’t actually tested and fed back into the school as increased draw for students, so a superior instructor with poor BS skills is at a disadvantage compared to a poor but smooth-talking instructor. Not so in BJJ, where your instructor’s Brazilian accent may be so thick that you barely know what he’s saying to begin with but his students’ competitive records may speak as eloquently as you ever need.
Originally Posted by Alex
Of course the same goes for other combat sports as for BJJ, and other non-combat sports as for Wing Chun in the above argument. (And yes, there are the very rare Wing Chun schools that produce fighters and the very rare, insular and non-competitive BJJ gyms.)
This is to you and whoever else commented on my two listed individuals. I meant that those two were the only ones whose seminars I have attended. There are plenty of others, no need to name them all. Sorry for the lack of clarification.
Originally Posted by FinalLegion
Just so we're clear, I meant that those two martial artists were the only ones whose seminar I have attended. There is no need to point out the many more, it is obvious.
Originally Posted by It is Fake
Sorry for the lack of clarification.
And you noticed what style I did because I have it listed I assume. Easy on the diatribe of my lack of semantics. I'll be sure to be more specific to avoid verbal confrontation, or rather, writing "inflammatory" statements.
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO