-
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- Vista, CA
- Posts
- 521
- Points
- 1,007


Posted On:
2/08/2012 9:08pm -
Light Heavyweight
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jun 2007
- Location
- East Bay, CA
- Posts
- 4,633
- Points
- 11,106


Posted On:
2/08/2012 9:19pm -
Registered Member
- Join Date
- Dec 2011
- Posts
- 174
- Points
- 393
Posted On:
2/08/2012 9:59pm -
Moderator
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2009
- Location
- Australia, Land of Oz
- Posts
- 4,948
- Points
- 9,082



Posted On:
2/08/2012 10:27pm--
Yeah, I don't get it, are you for or against the idea that without Bruce Lee there would be no MMA? Or are you against the fans nutriding Bruce and Dux? And I could not get more than five comments in to that exchange, sorry.
Seriously, without Bruce Lee there would be considerably less people influenced to take up martial arts in that era. A majority of a generation would not have been exposed to the "mystical Eastern arts". Kickboxing would probably still be considered unsporting as using the feet would still be seen as ungentlemanly. This could mean that various ninja, shogun, action movies, the show Kung Fu and the movie The Karate Kid would not be filmed, which would mean that both the real and the fake teachers of ninja and karate and taekwondo and other arts that could be marketed as the ultimate in self defence wouldn't see a spike in interest and participation in the 70s and 80s. This means less people convinced they are teh deadly at the end of the 80s, which means less varied participation in the Ultimate Fighting Challenge (ahem... Championship) of the 90s. And more chance that people are completely turned off by the fact that a grappler would hug a boxer into submission. Remember, this is a world where using the feet in a fight would still be a general no no.
Yeah, you'd have the people that engaged in no holds barred fighting and BJJ and Judo and boxing and Muay Thai, they'd still compete and probably even crosstrain. Without Bruce Lee, however, with stylised and well choreographed violence now on the big screen, there would not have been a gradual tolerance to that type of violence, so you think the laws are strict now regarding MMA as a sport, what with the stupid (in our eyes) rules regarding "downward" elbows and the like. Imagine a world that never became accustomed to any degree the site of a high kick to the face, imagine what they would say regarding a knee to the body, let alone a knee to the face. Go ahead and imagine it! Fucking do it before I high kick you in the face.
So, in conclusion, there would always be no holds barred fighting and cross training, but it would be very unlikely that there would be a sport like MMA.
What was the question? -
--
Oh my god people, I am most definitely AGAINST the idea that Bruce Lee invented MMA, as clearly stated in the sentence "Like any UFC fan with a working brain, I was puzzled to see the official UFC page spouting such complete bullshit."
Also, UFC would be UFC regardless if Lee was never even born. I give all the thanks to the Gracie family for this, not a movie actor. -
Registered Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- May 2010
- Location
- Riverside, CA
- Posts
- 565
- Points
- 804


Posted On:
2/08/2012 10:44pm -
Moderator
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2009
- Location
- Australia, Land of Oz
- Posts
- 4,948
- Points
- 9,082



Posted On:
2/08/2012 10:44pm--
First off, you misread it. It does not say the "inventor" of MMA, it says he is the "father" and my above hypotheticals would indicate this is somewhat accurate, being that he provided a seed for growth. Second off, why the **** wouldn't they "spout this bullshit" when there is so many UFC personnel involved in the project? Many of whom would most certainly say the man was a huge influence and factor in them taking up martial arts.
-
Senior Member
Achievements:- Join Date
- Feb 2010
- Location
- Arlie Beach
- Posts
- 2,029
- Points
- 2,957


Posted On:
2/08/2012 10:52pm
Style: mma /boxing/muai thai1
I was influenced by Elvis.
By the way do you think Bruce lee influenced the Australian fighting scene? This tended to be more of a BOB jones. And the taekwando guy who trained Tarak Solak. (Whos name I can't remember)
Otherwise. Do you think Vale tudo would not have happened? or Pride?Whitsunday Martial Arts Airlie Beach North Queensland.
http://www.facebook.com/#!/WhitsundayMartialArts -
Moderator
Achievements:- Join Date
- Jan 2009
- Location
- Australia, Land of Oz
- Posts
- 4,948
- Points
- 9,082



Posted On:
2/08/2012 11:12pm--
Of course they (PRIDE, Vale Tudo, UFC) would have happened, just like every other no holds barred event would have happened, eventually and to some degree. But the interest wouldn't be there because the exposure wouldn't have been there. The target market would be so greatly reduced that there would not be the take of money required to build it as a marketable option in the sporting world. This isn't rocket science.
It's pretty simple, remember that we are talking about an era where colour TV was new, there was no internet and the only people you interacted with were pretty much your mates, the locals and the work colleagues. There was no "here look at this youtube clip of a spinning back kick" there was the occasional big boxing match being played at the local pub. Bruce Lee was and is a household name, he forged a way into American cinema at a time when Asians were still being portrayed stereotypically and as comic relief. Fucking hell, he bridged fucking CULTURES and there's no love for the man?
DO NOT MISINTERPRET WHAT I AM SAYING. EVERYTHING WOULD HAVE EXISTED AND WOULD EXIST WITHOUT BRUCE LEE, JUST NOT IN ITS CURRENT MARKETABLE FORM.



Reply With Quote
















Welterweight
Posted On:
2/08/2012 8:00pm
Style: BJJ, MMA
Mind Numbing Stupidity on the UFC Facebook page