New criteria for fists are coming down the pike soon and we'll be re-activating the "Competition Videos" section, as a part of that.
Oh I don't think it should be as simple as that Phrosty.
I really don't want to get into forming committees and employing Robert's Rules of Order in order to determine if someone's sparred hard enough at a Throwdown. The point is to encourage people to get out there and spar hard, especially when they haven't done so before.
That's where the community experts, such as yourself, come in. I'm not saying we don't need some kind of informal way of giving a thumbs-up on it, just that I don't want it to be such a methodical process that we're creating bureaucracy over a simple icon.
If you want, you can be in charge of determining if someone gets a fist or not.