I think the problem is the forum you posted your question in
If in doubt YMAS
In answer to your OP, if I had someone in a hold down and they attempted to eyegouge/fish hook me I would attempt a Byker kiss
Trolling aside, I'm kinda surprised that nobody's answered "How do counter eye gouge after tackling?" with "armbar".
Transition to side control. Cross face with shoulder pressure to his jaw, turning his head to avoid the bite. Control far side arm with a one-handed ude garame/americana arm hold for security. He can't do ****. And if he does slip the arm hold and continue to try to gouge, apply the lock, and talk him down. "If you keep trying to bite me and gouge my eyes, I will break your arm." Once he's been warned, snap away if he keeps it up.
Or when he reaches up to gouge your eyes, pass the arm, slide head down and slip over to arm triangle him. Put him to sleep, then be sure to toss his shoes somewhere so that he can't easily give chase when he wakes up.
Here you go
I fucking love that submission at 2:00. It's my go-to when I feel like winning.
Oh wait, this is trollykate nevermind.