PDA

View Full Version : SO Much for Groundfighting a TRUE story... (linked)








Pages : 1 2 3 4 [5]

The Wastrel
2/13/2004 12:42am,
Just look at the Randori in Aikido, very effective agains multiple opponants.

You're going to give me seizures posting this crap.

katana
2/13/2004 1:27am,
Originally posted by PHILBERT
The Wastrel, actually I did think about what if I were the guy on the bottom.

On top, I'd get off and kick him then get the **** outta there in case he has buddies.

On bottom, I'd have to be there to know, see how he is throwing the punches, if they are straight punches, wild punches, hooks, etc and then attempt to get him off of me. Or just try punching him.

If you're mounted you can't punch the person on top with any effect. The article doesn't really make a point about groundfighting being bad at all. In fact if the guy who ended up on the bottom knew ground fighting he probably should have:

1) Hugged the guy on top closely to stop the effect of the blows.
2) Attempt to grap an arm and leg and bridge and roll out.
3) If the bridge failed then do a basic elbow knee escape.
4) Repeat basic steps 1-3 until success is achieved.

If he could do all three of those very basic things he could have gotten up faster to defend himself.

If the guy on top was more savvy he could have assumed the knee on stomach position to rain punches down on the bottom man. This way when his buddies came in he could have gotten up quickly to fend them off.

There are so many scenarios and responses to this situation that saying "SO much for groundfighting..." is really non-sense. What would the Kung Fu masters out there do? Sticky Hands? Trapping? Centerline defense and counterstrikes? How would that be any better than knowing basic mount escapes?

Hannibal
2/13/2004 2:39am,
Once again katana, an excellent point is made. So what? If the poor sod on the ground being pounded by the larger attacker was more skilled in groundfighting he could have had more success.But this article by no means shows groundfighting as ineffective.If anything it highlights the importance of knowing how to defend oneself on the ground. I've seen examples of martial artists who do stand up striking arts defeated by multiple attackers.It is very hard,even if you are a highly trained combatant to defend against three attackers kicking and punching you all at once.