PDA

View Full Version : Aikido Sucks



Pages : [1] 2

Shuma-Gorath
6/09/2007 4:15pm,
Welcome to the March 2007 edition of "HOW DO ARMBAR?", Bullshido's monthly themed column for making fun of your martial art. Yes, yours specifically. This month's featured style is Aikido, and while compiling these posts from other forums it reminded me of the proverbial bullet I dodged several years ago. You see, back when I was waking up from a Karate McDojo nightmare, I was looking to cross-train and "supplement" my training with some form of grappling. My known choices at the time were Judo or Aikido, and I thankfully chose Judo which led to me finding Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu at one of of the best schools in the country. Reading these forums was like that part in It's A Wonderful Life where George gets to see what the world would be like if he'd never been born, but instead of not being born I was wearing a hakama and benchmarked my skill on how well I can off-balance a drunken man with an inner-ear problem.


Aikiweb

I personally didn't make a Ki ball because I was over on one of the other mats resurrecting a chicken.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/01-kiball.png


Some days I wish we still lived in a society where we could subject these people to dunking cages.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/02-psychic.png


If this post were true and Ueshiba really was gifted with a enlightened superhuman mind, I still doubt he'd be able to figure out what it was trying to say about him and his art.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/03-ueshiba.png


Does anyone remember the Moons of Jupiter aikidoka who would shower with his students? This is what happens when you cross him with a Tool song and a carnival palm-reader.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/04-saturn_comes_back_around.png


I'm personally more interested in the ability to summon speeding buses from thin air than the ability to throw people without touching them.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/05-my_love_for_you_is_like_.png


The main problem with this post isn't that this guy jumps black belts after class or even that he can beat them up, but that he thinks you can swim on a "matt".
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/06-confused.png


If you're going to whimper and flee from an unarmed grappler you might want to change that signature.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/07-juxtaposition.png


While you're busy negating the athleticism and other secondary benefits of proper training, you might as well have your "pure self-defense" situation include the aikidoka riding a unicorn.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/08-unicorn.png


Martial Arts Planet's Aikido forum

I suppose seiza position doubles as drilling for this kind of thing.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/01-begging_optional.png


Since my limited experience with aikijujitsu consisted of someone trying to poke me behind the ear from under mount, I'm guessing that's one of the techniques that required ki (since it didn't work).
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/02-how_do_kichi.png


Since an observer cannot feel functional aikido being applied, its application cannot be filmed and no one knows whether or not it requires ki, achieving proficiency in the art causes you to become intangible, invisible and unquantifiable by the laws of modern science.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/03-quantum-ki_leap.png


It's too bad that if you bought his book you're probably already dead on the inside.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/04-dont_cry_im_already.png


Aikido must make you one with some other universe since you obviously don't live in ours.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/05-then_come_back_to_it_plz.png


I used to think wing chun lineage wars were bad, but at least they've moved past the point of deciding whether or not their art allows them to punch.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/06-what_indeed.png


This anatomy lesson by one of the MAP staff members might explain why the aikidoka who switched over to my BJJ club got the nickname "Frankenstein".
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/07-ok_done_here.png


I think I've finally constructed what Aikido is: It's 90% atemi which you aren't doing if you're kicking or punching and you use the muscles of the opponent that you don't have in order to not fight him while you run away. Once you satisfy all these contradictions you will achieve world peace, and we can all wear nice little hats and skip around holding hands while being smug about the complexity of our art.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/finale.png


monsterland: Scourge of Something Awful's Ask/Tell forum
(Disclaimer: Something Awful is a great forum, but unfortunately typical aikido passive-aggressiveness slides through the cracks. It's analogous to how the art only works if you can call the police when someone makes you cry.)

"If a famous person follows along with my implausible scenario and puts themself in a ridiculous position then Aikido can work. Oh yeah, I also need to do this in a bus." The quoted post got about five similar responses, each more incredulous than the last.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/01-rickson_phone.png


Oh yeah, well what if I drive the bus into a ring? THEN WHAT, HUH?
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/02-what_about_a_bus_in_a_ri.png


"Bigger"? "Can be developed into"? It sounds like Aikido is an obese man who needs to be put on a treadmill before he can physically fit into an MMA octagon.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/03-in_ego_only.png


In closing we give you not an internet post about Aikido, but a demonstration of Aikido as applied to internet posting.
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/goodbye-01.png
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/goodbye-02.png
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/goodbye-03.png
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/../gallery/data/589/goodbye-04.png


If any aikidoka are offended by this article, you will be glad to know that your terrible posts have driven me to drink and thus be transformed into your ideal opponent. Should you wish to exact revenge by not confronting me and being condescending about how complicated your art is, I will further add to your advantage by taking the bus home.

ronin497
8/07/2007 5:49pm,
Five years ago I would have angry closed the browser window after reading your thread...But I haven't done Aikido in five years - and I have to say that I agree with many of your barbs against the art. Balls of Chi and all that. O-Sensei himself seemed like something of a loon. Fortunately, I studied in a system that seemed to be more pragmatic in its approach. I was never told to "draw the cosmos into my lungs" or "harmonize with the universe and whatnot." Despite the fact that Aikido only seems to be 100 percent effective in an environment with more than enough room for the person to maneuver, doesn't it seem a little dismissive to write off an entire discipline based on the "ki-ball throwers?" I caveat that - If that's what you were doing. If I misread your intentions, I apologize in advance. Unlike many Aikidoka I know, I can admit when I'm wrong. Which happens an awful lot. At any rate - many of the weapon defense techniques seem valid...although this is coming from someone who's never been attacked with a weapon more dangerous than a ham sandwich. I welcome your reply...and in the meantime I wonder...the Aikido instruction that you had - was it by chance Ki Society? Those guys kinda rub me as wackos.

Adam Alexander
8/08/2007 7:18pm,
Come on now, there was some practical balance in the Aikiweb thread. In the actual thread, there's plenty of people "gently" telling them they're nuts.

For the record, I don't believe in ki-balls.

ronin497
8/08/2007 9:58pm,
Whoa whoa whoa hey. Ki-Balls DO exist. Peter North shoots his off all the time.

breakdown1101
9/17/2007 8:56am,
Ki balls do exist.I hunt down dinosaurs with them

Nihonto
12/25/2007 11:30pm,
I used to do Aikido - switched to BJJ.

I cultivate Ki and generate Ki-balls whenever trying to pass guard on senior belts (I'm a white belt). It hasn't worked yet ... but a loud Kiai when doing Umpa escape from mount sure gets everyone's attention, and it works on other white belts ;)

AikiZenDragon
12/26/2007 9:34pm,
ki balls lol... i am constantly amazed how on a forum where people want to be thorough and objective in their analysis of MA and MA techniques, some of the participants want to continue to give half assed reviews/ articles about something they have only briefly even had any instruction in and fail to give specifically where and from whom they received instruction... i am always the first to say that most aikido schools are lame, hell for that matter most MA schools of any type tend to be bullshit because it is popular and any asshat can open a school with little, none or fraudulent credentials. please post something useful like where to find good hard, practical aikido schools or what aiki dancing pussified schools to avoid... please include lineage/style...

hughesjd
3/12/2008 10:55am,
When I was a much younger lad I used to believe in the bunny foo arts. I even studied them. Then, the best thing possible happened. I joined the High School wrestling team... been a believer in the power of hard work and the grappling arts ever since! The real grappling arts, not wristy-twisty ones.

FickleFingerOfFate
3/12/2008 11:03am,
When I was a much younger lad I used to believe in the bunny foo arts. I even studied them. Then, the best thing possible happened. I joined the High School wresling team... been a believer in the power of hard work and the grappling arts ever since! The real grappling arts, not wristy-twisty ones.




Sweet mother of a necropheliac God!


Get you ass to Newbietown, Pronto!

hughesjd
3/12/2008 11:42am,
Sweet mother of a necropheliac God!


Get you ass to Newbietown, Pronto!

LOL I said I've grown out of it!

berkoff62
6/19/2009 6:03pm,
Hello im kind of new here, Ive been doing aikido (brown belt) for some years now, must say its not perfect as mentioned before, but with training and time if can be satisfying, must say Ive used it few times on the streets and is not as flashy as people think you dont get to move the guy around you 6 times like some star wars aikidokas out there but I can say certainly works this of course depends on factors like momentum etc, also let us remember that it will never be the same to fight a martial artist than some mugger or just some stupid fight we may come across

berkoff62
6/19/2009 6:24pm,
first comment no wars or assassination promises pls

DCS
6/19/2009 7:35pm,
first comment no wars or assassination promises pls


http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ivpn7lWFNEw/SJMx-eSb7xI/AAAAAAAABGk/Ck959GbzMJ8/s400/YouGonnaGetLoved.jpg

I suggest you to stay in noobtown at least for 2 weeks. Lurk more and post less.

kthxbai.

kenpostudent
6/19/2009 7:46pm,
Hello im kind of new here, Ive been doing aikido (brown belt) for some years now, must say its not perfect as mentioned before, but with training and time if can be satisfying, must say Ive used it few times on the streets and is not as flashy as people think you dont get to move the guy around you 6 times like some star wars aikidokas out there but I can say certainly works this of course depends on factors like momentum etc, also let us remember that it will never be the same to fight a martial artist than some mugger or just some stupid fight we may come across

How do you make aikido work against anything other than a completely telegraphed attack?

TheMarquis
7/09/2009 5:21pm,
Just read this from the start... Jesus titty fucking Christ...

There that sums up my initial reaction.

Rob Barton
7/14/2009 6:50pm,
I always liked the explanation of Ki given by Fredrick Lovret in The Wat and the Power when he looks at what the word means and how it is used in the language and blows the BS right off of it.