PDA

View Full Version : Investigating Nidan Claim








Melkolmr
8/15/2011 10:42pm,
One of the instructors at a karate school nearby where I live claims to be ranked nidan in Judo under a Sensei Isaku Suzuki. I can't find any records regarding either Isaku Suzuki or the instructor, Robert Ornes, simply by searching Google or the USJI/F/A sites. Is there an efficient way to confirm or discredit this rank?

BKR
8/15/2011 11:38pm,
This probably should be moved to MABS as you are doing an investigation.

In short, ask the guy under which national organization he was awarded his rank.

Melkolmr
8/16/2011 2:07am,
Alright, thank you. I didn't want to jump the gun and call this a serious MABS investigation until I knew the next step to take, but I will ask soon enough.

The website, for anyone interested, is www.askd.us - American Shodokan Kodokan Dojos.

kitkatninja
8/16/2011 2:37am,
...In short, ask the guy under which national organization he was awarded his rank.

This would be the first step :)

-Ken

NeilG
8/16/2011 2:12pm,
Just glancing through that website raises red flags for me, but I can't find anything much about it either here or on e-budo.

BKR
8/16/2011 2:12pm,
Alright, thank you. I didn't want to jump the gun and call this a serious MABS investigation until I knew the next step to take, but I will ask soon enough.

The website, for anyone interested, is www.askd.us - American Shodokan Kodokan Dojos.

You might inquire as to where/when he studied Judo with Mr. Suzuki, that would help narrow things down.

I didn't see any mention of Judo instruction on the website, did I miss something?

judoka_uk
8/16/2011 2:30pm,
You might inquire as to where/when he studied Judo with Mr. Suzuki, that would help narrow things down.

I didn't see any mention of Judo instruction on the website, did I miss something?
http://www.askd.us/head_instructors_bio

Skip down to Robert Ornes and then to his other ranks held. Its the first one listed.

Outis
8/16/2011 8:13pm,
Other ranks held by Sensei R. Ornes
2nd-degree Black Belt in Judo earned by Sensei Isaku Suzuki

Apparently the rank held by Ornes was earned by Suzuki.

BKR
8/16/2011 9:48pm,
http://www.askd.us/head_instructors_bio

Skip down to Robert Ornes and then to his other ranks held. Its the first one listed.

I saw the claim of rank, but nothing on the website about teaching Judo, just karate.

Ben

Melkolmr
8/16/2011 11:29pm,
The instruction there is, as far as I have been informed, just karate. Basically the Strip-mall Shotokan Special: pressure points, point-sparring and kata.

BKR
8/18/2011 3:33pm,
The instruction there is, as far as I have been informed, just karate. Basically the Strip-mall Shotokan Special: pressure points, point-sparring and kata.

Run away, then, if they are not teaching Judo his rank claim doesn't really matter.

Melkolmr
8/22/2011 12:48am,
I can update that a little bit: they go over "Judo" on occasion, which has been described thusly: "We get on our knees, grab the other guy's gi here (indicating collar) and try to turn him onto his back."

jtkarate
8/24/2011 8:49pm,
I can update that a little bit: they go over "Judo" on occasion, which has been described thusly: "We get on our knees, grab the other guy's gi here (indicating collar) and try to turn him onto his back."

Thats not judo ...thats Foreplay

Mudansha
9/12/2011 5:30am,
Thats not judo ...thats Foreplay

That's hilarious... :P

I am a nanadan in Google-fu and I find NO other reference to an instructor named Isaku Suzuki.

I can't say there isn't one... but chances are low...